Urban sustainability efforts have historically failed to advance all three E’s of sustainability: environmental action, economic development, and equity. However, a movement is underway to put equity—the oft-ignored E—at the forefront.
In the vacuum of national policy leadership and international consensus on climate action, cities around the world are ramping up local-level climate initiatives. The imperative for urban planning and policy action on climate is undeniable. The majority of people around the world live in cities, cities account for a significant amount of global greenhouse gas emissions, and cities are particularly vulnerable to the impacts of climate change. For local climate action planning efforts to have maximum positive impact, they must prioritize all three E's of sustainability: environmental action, economic development, and social equity.
For an example of how cities can advance the three E's in a meaningful way, look to the Portland Clean Energy Initiative. Van Jones recently called it the "most important ballot initiative in the country."
Sure, Portland, Oregon has long been renowned as a "sustainable city." But like in other cities, Portland's green sustainability successes have been inequitably distributed (see Goodling, Green & MicClintock, 2015). Meanwhile, the city's residents of color experience significant disparities relative to white people, documented in a series of “unsettling profiles” by the Coalition of Communities of Color. Low-income residents are being displaced from the city via intense gentrification. In short, Portland is more of a case study in unbalanced sustainability than in a three-pronged approach.
But a measure on the ballot this November signals an important change in the sustainability movement in Portland. The Portland Clean Energy Initiative measure thoughtfully advances all three E’s of sustainability and climate action.
The Portland Clean Energy Initiative is expected to raise over $30 million annually in new revenue, up to 75 percent of which will fund energy efficiency upgrades, home weatherization (lowering utility bills for renters and homeowners), community-scale renewable energy, tree planting, and urban greening, all while prioritizing Portland’s most vulnerable neighborhoods. Another 25 percent of the revenue generated by the initiative is intended for green job training that prioritizes economically disadvantaged workers, including the chronically underemployed, communities of color, people with disabilities, and women.
The new revenue will come from a one percent surcharge on the Portland business license for mega-retail businesses only—those with revenue above $1 billion per year and above $500,000 annually within city limits. Proponents emphasize that there is no evidence to suggest this surcharge will be passed on to consumers. To assuage concern about regressive impacts, revenue from groceries, medicine, and health care services are exempted.
The call for a three-pronged approach in municipal-scale sustainability like this is not new. In 1996, one of the most cited planning articles of the past century called for urban planners to focus not just on "green cities and growing cities" but also on "just cities." Likewise, Julian Agyeman, Robert Bullard, and Bob Evans called on urban leaders in 2003 to adopt the concept of just sustainabilities, or the need to ensure a "better quality of life for all, now, and into the future, in a just and equitable manner, whilst living within the limits of supporting ecosystems."
While sustainability and the three E's have become a defining principle of good urban planning, actual on-the-ground practice has often fallen short. Sustainability efforts have often heavily favored one E, economic growth, at the expense of environmental protection or improvements in social equity. In a Planetizen feature in 2007, planning scholar Dr. Michael Gunder warned that "Planning practitioners need to carefully reflect on their role... Otherwise, planners may continue to conflate the triple-bottom-line of environment, social equity, and economy together in a manner that risks both the environment and social equity in the name of sustainable wealth creation for the dominant minority profiting from competitive globalization." Likewise, other sustainability scholars (e.g., Pearsall and Pierce, 2010; Finn and McCormack, 2011) have examined municipal sustainability and climate action plans and found them weak in terms of attention to equitable economic development and environmental justice.
Meanwhile, historically disadvantaged people continue to experience the cumulative impacts of environmental, racial, and socioeconomic burdens. Nationwide, low-income Latino and African American households proportionally spend an average of three times more of their salary on utilities than wealthy Americans do, according to a 2016 American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy study. Hundreds of studies on environmental justice document how poor populations and people of color are more likely to live near hazardous waste sites and sources of air pollution, have access to fewer environmental benefits such as parks, experience less stringent enforcement of environmental regulations, and are excluded from environmental decision-making. Consequently, they experience worse health outcomes and are more vulnerable to the effects of climate change, like intense heat events and storms.
The Portland Clean Energy Initiative is a true collaboration among civil rights and social justice organizations, including the Asian and Pacific Islander Network of Oregon, the Coalition of Communities of Color, the Native American Youth and Family Center, and the NAACP Portland chapter, as well as more environmentally focused organizations like the Audubon Society of Portland, the Oregon chapter of the Sierra Club, and Columbia Riverkeeper, and environmental justice groups that have long bridged the two movements, like OPAL Environmental Justice Portland and Verde. As Jenny Lee, advocacy director at the Coalition of Communities of Color said in an interview with Grist, "It’s groundbreaking… It’s the first environmental or climate initiative, as far as we know, that’s been led by organizations of color in Oregon...It’s a very clear statement that we are here, we are leading on policy, and we are also building political power."
Portland voters will have a chance to vote YES on Portland Clean Energy Initiative this November. Regardless, the initiative is an example for planners and urban sustainability policy makers that embraces the full three prongs of sustainability and there are some valuable insights other cities can glean: 1) forge alliances among civil rights/social justice and environmental organizations; 2) prioritize investments in neighborhoods, communities, and individuals that have historically experienced environmental injustices; 3) ensure that green jobs will pay living wages and are targeted to economically disadvantaged workers; 4) counter gentrification; and (5) seek funding from the economic elite.
Find out more about the Portland Clean Energy Initiative here.
Megan Horst, PhD, AICP, is an assistant professor in the Toulan School of Urban Studies and Planning at Portland State University, where she teaches about and researches urban planning and environmental justice, especially food justice. More about Dr. Horst here.
Making Healthy Places
The editors of the book "Making Healthy Places," recently published in a second edition by Island Press, discuss the intersections of public health and planning, including key concepts such as green gentrification, health impact assessments, and AI.
Where Housing Costs Are Falling Fastest
Although median home prices remain close to record highs in many cities, some of the country’s priciest metro areas are seeing home prices plummet.
Chicago ADUs Concentrated in More Affluent Neighborhoods
An analysis of city-issued permits shows that homeowners in gentrified wards are building accessory dwelling units at much higher rates than those in less well-off communities.
The Great American Exodus: A Conservative's Perspective
During his keynote speech on September 11 at the National Conservatism Conference in Miami, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis describes the demographic shifts in America since he became governor in 2019 in what he calls the 'Great American Exodus.'
$100 Million to Help Fund Buffalo Bayou Expansion in Houston
Originally proposed in 2019, the Buffalo Park East Master Plan, which would extend Buffalo Bayou Park to the East End and Fifth Ward neighborhoods, is suddenly in high gear.
Community Land Trusts Make Homeownership Accessible
The organizations sell homes to low-income buyers at rates far below market prices, putting homeownership within reach for more families.
HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research
Smart City Expo World Congress
Daniel R. Mandelker
California High Speed Rail Authority
City of Fargo, North Dakota
City of Crystal River
This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.