Why Is Transit Ridership Declining?

Over the past two years or so, transit ridership has begun to decline. It seems that this decline has been most widespread among cities with relatively weak transit systems.

Read Time: 3 minutes

January 16, 2018, 5:00 AM PST

By Michael Lewyn @mlewyn

Broken Bus

mastermaq / flickr

Between 1995 and 2015, American transit ridership rose from 7.8 billion trips to 10.6 billion. But over the past couple of years, transit ridership in most cities has began to dip. Between the third quarter of 2016 and the third quarter of 2017, U.S.ridership declined by 3 percent. (Ridership also declined slightly in 2015.)

Why has ridership been declining? I’d like to focus on two possible explanations. One explanation focuses on the rise of alternatives to both private automobiles and public transit, such as Uber and bicycling. 

If this explanation were a major factor, we would expect to see ridership declines in the cities where taxicabs and bicycling were most common. Although I have found no data on taxi use by city, I would guess that these cities would be the most compact, walkable, transit-oriented cities. There are four major cities where fewer than half of urban commuters use a car to get to work: Boston, New York, San Francisco and Washington. In all four cities, transit ridership decreased by 3-5 percent over the last year, roughly the same as the national average. In 2015-16, transit ridership actually increased in three of the four cities (all but Washington).

Adding Philadelphia, Seattle, and Chicago (where 60-67 percent of commuters drive) doesn’t change this result very much: Chicago’s 2016-17 decline was close to the national average, Philadelphia declined a bit more (by just over 5 percent), and Seattle ridership rose. Similarly, in 2015-16 transit ridership rose in Seattle, while declining modestly (1-3 percent) in Philadelphia and Chicago. In sum, ridership in the least auto-oriented cities is roughly in line with national trends; it seems to me that if taxis and bicycling were the major cause of ridership decline, those cities would be experiencing larger ridership declines than other cities.

A second explanation focuses on economic growth; as the economy has improved and gas prices have flattened out, it might be the case that more working-class riders can afford to buy cars, and that a few riders who already owned cars can afford to drive more. Thus, people who could not afford cars during the recession have become "choice riders" and that some of them have exercised the choice to drive.  

It seems to me that if this view were correct, transit ridership would decline most significantly in cities where most people use cars daily—for example, cities in which over 90 percent of commuters drive to work. Major cities in this category include Columbus, El Paso, Fort Worth, Indianapolis, Jacksonville, Memphis, Nashville, and San Antonio. The data modestly supports this hypothesis: in five of the eight cities, ridership declined more than the national average (by between 4 and 7 percent) between the third quarter of 2016 and the third quarter of 2017. Ridership declined by about the same as the national average in Indianapolis, and by less than the average in Nashville(2 percent) and Columbus (0.7 percent).   

What about in 2015-16 (when national ridership declined by 1.6 percent)? In six of the eight "90 percent car" cities, transit ridership declined by more than the national average, ranging from 4 percent in Nashville to 8 percent in Fort Worth. In two other cities (Columbus and Jacksonville), ridership declined but by less than 1 percent.

On balance, it seems that ridership has declined the most in cities where transit was already rather weak, and thus that the national ridership decline may be related to the growing economy. But next year's data might support a different hypothesis.

Michael Lewyn

Michael Lewyn is an associate professor at Touro College, Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center, in Long Island. His scholarship can be found at http://works.bepress.com/lewyn.

Green bike lane with flexible delineators and textures paint in Hoboken, New Jersey

America’s Best New Bike Lanes

PeopleForBikes highlights some of the most exciting new bike infrastructure projects completed in 2022.

January 31, 2023 - PeopleforBikes

Aerial view of MBTA commuter rail station in Concord, Massachusetts among green trees

Massachusetts Zoning Reform Law Reaches First Deadline

Cities and towns had until January 31 to submit their draft plans for rezoning areas near transit stations to comply with a new state law.

February 1, 2023 - Streetsblog Mass

Green alley under construction

Green Alleys: A New Paradigm for Stormwater Management

Rather than shuttling stormwater away from the city and into the ocean as quickly as possible, Los Angeles is now—slowly—moving toward a ‘city-as-sponge’ approach that would capture and reclaim more water to recharge crucial reservoirs.

February 2, 2023 - Curbed

Green Line, Los Angeles

Rail Transit Plans Would Connect L.A.’s South Bay to the Regional Rail System

Two new transit extensions promise several new routes for South Bay residents to access the Los Angeles region’s transit system.

2 minutes ago - The Source

Texas Capitol Building

Property Appraisal Caps Unlikely to Pass in Texas

Critics of a proposal to limit property value increases to reduce homeowners’ property tax burden say the measure would destabilize the housing market and cause cities to raise other taxes to compensate.

1 hour ago - Houston Chronicle

Aerial view of residential development near beach in Oahu, Hawaii

Hawaii State Bills Could Limit or Expand Affordable Housing Law

Some legislators see a law that provides a zoning exemption to affordable housing builders as a necessary way to alleviate the housing crisis, while others worry about the impact of fast-tracked development on land zoned for conservation.

2 hours ago - Honolulu Civil Beat

Write for Planetizen

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.