Urban Demographics: The New Elite

Economist Jed Kolko's recent study on how the lack in affordability of cities determines who's moving there, whose moving out, and how these changes are shaping cities and suburbs. His paper is the basis for several articles by leading urban writers.

April 6, 2016, 8:00 AM PDT

By Irvin Dawid


Welcome to Brooklyn

photo.ua / Shutterstock

I find it amazing how much one researcher's work can help inspire so many excellent writers. Jed Kolko's latest study on urban demographics, "Urban Revival? Not For Most Americans," is cited by Matthew Yglesias of Vox, Emily Badger of The Washington Post Wonkblog, and Derek Thompson of The Atlantic, in their articles describing demographic changes in major cities in the U.S.

The Vox piece, in turn, is cited by columnist Paul Krugman of The New York Times, though it would appear that Republican presidential candidate Sen. Ted Cruz (Texas), specifically for the use of the term, "New York Values," may have inspired his column.

The most interesting lede goes to Derek Thompson, senior editor at The Atlantic, who writes that to say that "millennials are living in cities" is not very accurate. It's important to add these demographic qualifiers:

  • "Only those with a four-year college degree and incomes in the top 40 percent
  • "Mostly the ones without school-age kids
  • "[M]ostly just the ones that are white."

However, this is not a "millennial" story. They just help to describe the changing demographics of cities.

  • "The richest 10 percent of households were most likely to move into dense urban areas between 2000 and 2014."
  • "The poorest 10 percent fled cities the fastest." 
  • "Meanwhile, the U.S. is becoming much more urban for the white childless elite, and much more suburban for everybody else."

Thompson goes on to describe interesting finds on suburban changes. Sticking with cities, remember the dense, turn-of-the-century tenements marked by extreme poverty? It's been turned on its head. Now "the fastest growing urban areas among this privileged demographic are the most dense—places like Manhattan and Brooklyn, San Francisco, Boston, Washington, D.C.," writes Thompson.

Emily Badger writes about these changes that are readily apparent in the District of Columbia.

Clearly, something big has been happening in the District. The construction cranes prove as much. Whole neighborhoods have been redeveloped, and urban housing prices have skyrocketed. Demographics have perceptibly shifted in the blocks right around the city's metro stops. The District's population has grown by about 90,000 people in the last decade.

Badger calls Washington "a national outlier, and even in this region, the shift toward urban living is driven by a smaller sliver of people than we usually acknowledge."

As Thompson notes, add Manhattan, Brooklyn, San Francisco, and Boston to this elite group. I'd suggest adding even parts of Queens.

But clearly not all large cities are experiencing what Thompson likens to a "geographical Gilded Age." Chicago is not faring well population-wise and "might be a harbinger for other great American cities." He explains what's gone wrong in Chicago to Here & Now's host, Jeremy Hobson, and how to address it.

Hat tip to Loren Spiekerman.

Wednesday, March 30, 2016 in The Atlantic

Walkable Urban Commercial District

The Complexities of the '15-Minute City'

What does a '15-minute city' truly mean–and how achievable is it in the U.S.?

July 29, 2021 - Governing

Toronto Freeway

Does Highway Removal Make Cities Healthier?

Highway removal can improve the air quality and health of the immediate environment, but displacement and gentrification threaten to exclude former residents from the benefits.

July 30, 2021 - NextCity

Pioneer Square, Seattle

Tree Equity Score: The U.S. Needs 522 Million More Urban Trees

As climate change intensifies the urban heat island effect, poorer neighborhoods bear the brunt of tree canopy inequity.

July 28, 2021 - The Urbanist

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Hand Drawing Master Plans

This course aims to provide an introduction into Urban Design Sketching focused on how to hand draw master plans using a mix of colored markers.