Keep up with essential planning news and commentary, delivered to your inbox every Monday and Thursday.
A Tale of Two Chelseas
"Census and city figures show that the average household income in Chelsea, about $140,000, is almost five times the average for households in public housing in the area," according to Mireya Navarro. "The neighborhood now ranks among those in the city with the greatest income inequality, according to the Furman Center for Real Estate and Urban Policy at New York University, as the share of households in the highest income brackets — over $250,000 — has grown."
The article notes the ongoing tension behind two housing initiatives moving forward under the direction of Mayor Bill de Blasio: the upzoning of East New York and a proposal to build new housing on properties controlled by the New York City Housing Authority. Both of those proposals have sparked concerns among residents that they will be displaced by rising costs connected with new developments. Navarri cites Chelsea's example for some perspective on the current controversy affecting those parts of the city.
"In long-gentrified Chelsea, the worst fears have yet to come true. The housing projects — Fulton Houses (between 16th and 19th Streets and Ninth and 10th Avenues) and the neighboring Elliot and Chelsea Houses (in the mid-20s) — with about 2,000 apartments combined, are still there, as they have been since the 1940s (Elliot) and ’60s (Fulton and Chelsea). The brick buildings have deteriorated, however, under the weight of time and as the Housing Authority’s maintenance budget has fallen short, although city officials say they remain committed to preserving public housing."
The article goes onto describe how the dichotomy of income levels impacts the people on the low end of the spectrum—citing some examples of how policy neglects the block-by-block discrepancies of neighborhoods like Chelsea when data is only considered at the ZIP Code level.