Dumping in Dixie and the Inequity of Place

Only by better addressing issues of inequity can we create truly sustainable and livable communities. But is that even possible today?

5 minute read

December 15, 2014, 5:00 AM PST

By Mark Hough

March for Environmental Justice

United Workers / Flickr

“Addressing issues of inequity is a prerequisite to creating sustainable and livable communities.” This was the big message put forth recently by Robert Bullard—the proclaimed “father of environmental justice”—to a large group of landscape architects in Denver for the annual meeting of the American Society of Landscape Architects (ASLA). There was an unplanned timeliness to his talk, as it coincided with the explosive events unfolding in Ferguson, Missouri. While he did not directly reference them, the racially charged tensions brewing in the country at the time provided an unspoken and powerful subtext to his point that communities in this country are not treated equally.

Bullard is a sociologist by training and self-identifies as an “accidental environmentalist.” He is the Dean of the School of Public Affairs at Texas Southern University and has spent much of his career studying the demographics and geography of poverty, race, public health and environmental equity. His focus on this began in the late 1970s, when he was brought in as an expert witness on a lawsuit fighting a decision to put a city landfill in an overwhelmingly African American neighborhood in Houston. Along with his students, he mapped major landfills, garbage dumps and incinerators in the city and found that almost all had been located in such neighborhoods, even though blacks made up only a quarter of the population of the city at the time.

This is by no means an isolated incident. There are enough documented cases of eco-racism (or “PIBBY” – Put It in Blacks’ Backyards) to make it a systemic problem, especially in the South, which Bullard says is “the most environmentally degraded region in the nation.” It is also the most vulnerable. He backs all of this up in his 2000 book, Dumping in Dixie, which tackles the roots of race-based environmental justice.

One particularly sinister case he addresses took place in the early 1980s in Warren County, North Carolina – one of the poorest counties in the state, and the one with the highest percentage of African American residents. A decision was made to bury over 30,000 cubic yards of soil contaminated with a high concentration of toxic PCBs in a community that was, at the time, 84% black. The community protested, but the dumping occurred anyway. The soil remains today, and will likely leak into the drinking water at some point, making this not only an issue of social or environmental injustice, but also one of public health. “One of the most potent predictors of health,” Bullard says, “is zip code.”

March in Warren County, NC in 1982  Photo by Matt Cooper

The origins of this issue in the South are obvious, yet the solutions are anything but. Although progress has been made on certain fronts, the fundamental dynamic persists. Since the 1970s, businesses have flocked to Southern states from other parts of the country in search of a cheaper workforce and lower taxes. While this has helped state economies, it has also exaggerated an existing societal and geographic stratification. White collar and other so-called “clean” industries have typically been sited out in the suburbs, while heavily polluting industries – paper mills, oil refineries, waste disposal facilities, chemical plants, and the like – have disproportionately ended up in or near poor, inner city neighborhoods that are often home to concentrated populations of African Americans trapped by poverty, a lack of access to public transportation and discriminatory housing policies.

The Center for Disease Control has clearly documented how Southern states consistently rank among the least healthy, with high rates of heart disease, obesity, asthma, diabetes, cancer, and so on. It is hard to argue against the direct correlation that exists between the health of a community and the quality of the environment in which it is located. This is the reason you won’t find the “blackbelt” states – those aligned from the Carolinas to Louisiana – on the ubiquitous lists awarding the greenest, fittest, or most bike and pedestrian friendly cities in the country. Those cities are most often in Midwestern and Western states, where there is plenty of access to clean air, water, trees and quality open space. Place matters.

Prevalence of Diabetes in the US, 2011 Data from CDC

Bullard presented all of this information to a rapt audience in Denver. As a born, raised and resident Southerner, it was not all easy for me to hear. Nor, however, was it all that surprising. There was no grand epiphany at the end of his talk – no feel-good optimism that landscape architects could institute real change by just designing more parks. He left no easy way out.

His basic message about the unjust cycle of poverty was sadly – yet somehow comically – juxtaposed against the news that a strangely over-the-top floating park had been proposed in the Hudson River alongside Manhattan’s West Side. The bulk of the project's $170 million price tag will come from billionaire neighbors Barry Diller and Diane von Furstenberg, who commissioned the design. I have no problem with people spending their own money to help improve their neighborhood; a lot of obvious good comes with that. It is just that vanity projects like this hit home the fact that public space isn't quite as public as perhaps it should be. It, like everything else, is a commodity that can be sold to the highest bidder.

Proposal for Pier 55 in the Hudson River Image by Heatherwick Studios

While the glorious transformation of the public realm continues in wealthy cities like New York, it is hard to believe meaningful change is anywhere on the horizon for poor communities in the South. States there continue to overwhelmingly elect politicians who deny the seriousness of a racial divide while championing a pro-business, small government ideology that is fundamentally at odds with the ideals set forth by the Affordable Care Act, affirmative action policies, and public assistance programs that so many people depend on. Gerrymandering and successful attempts at dismantling the Voting Rights Act are helping to ensure this course will likely not change any time soon.

The bottom line is that we live in a country where the haves will continue to have, and the have nots will continue to need. A certain element of that is, of course, unavoidable. However, as recent data prove, the gap between the two is growing.

I wonder whether perpetuating the myth that all Americans share an equal opportunity for success is, in some ways, making it harder to fix the problems of inequality. Not only does it instill a false hope for communities at the bottom of the scale, it also preserves a status quo that has failed to live up to a promise of justice—social, economic, and environmental—for all.

Mark Hough

Mark Hough has been the university landscape architect at Duke University since 2000. He is involved in all aspects of planning and design on the ever-evolving campus. Outside of Duke, he writes and lectures on topics such as cities, campuses, sustainability and cultural landscapes. He is a frequent contributor to Landscape Architecture Magazine and has written for other publications, including Places Journal, Chronicle of Higher Education, and College Planning and Management.

Large blank mall building with only two cars in large parking lot.

Pennsylvania Mall Conversion Bill Passes House

If passed, the bill would promote the adaptive reuse of defunct commercial buildings.

April 18, 2024 - Central Penn Business Journal

Street scene in Greenwich Village, New York City with people walking through busy intersection and new WTC tower in background.

Planning for Accessibility: Proximity is More Important than Mobility

Accessibility-based planning minimizes the distance that people must travel to reach desired services and activities. Measured this way, increased density can provide more total benefits than increased speeds.

April 14, 2024 - Todd Litman

Wood-frame two-story rowhouses under construction.

Fair Housing Cannot Take a Back Seat to ‘Build, Baby, Build’

If we overlook fair housing principles in the plan to build US housing back better, we risk ending up right back where we started.

April 11, 2024 - James Jennings

"No 710" lawn sign on green lawn.

LA Metro Board Approves New 710 Freeway Plan

The newest plan for the 710 corridor claims it will not displace any residents.

3 hours ago - Streetsblog LA

Close-up of row of electric cars plugged into chargers at outdoor station.

Austin’s Proposed EV Charging Rules Regulate Station Locations, Size

City planners say the new rules would ensure an efficient distribution of charging infrastructure across the city and prevent an overconcentration in residential areas.

4 hours ago - Austin Monitor

Green hills with orange California poppies in bloom in foreground in Chino Hills State Park, California.

Making California State Parks More Climate-Resilient

A recently released report offers recommendations for keeping state parks healthy and robust, including acquiring additional land for conservation and recreation.

5 hours ago - Spectrum News 1

News from HUD User

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Call for Speakers

Mpact Transit + Community

New Updates on PD&R Edge

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Write for Planetizen

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.