Highways And Labor Markets II

One accurate measurement can be more insightful than a thousand expert opinions. In a recent blog titled, Livability and All That, highway expert Alan Pisarski argues that highway-oriented transport systems are necessary for efficient consumer and labor markets.

4 minute read

December 9, 2010, 6:55 AM PST

By Todd Litman


One accurate measurement can be more insightful than a thousand expert opinions.

In a recent blog titled, Livability and All That, highway expert Alan Pisarski argues that highway-oriented transport systems are necessary for efficient consumer and labor markets. In Highways and Labor Markets, fellow Planetizen blogger Michael Lewyn challenged Pisarski's assumptions by pointing out that residents of walkable and transit-oriented neighborhoods generally have better overall access to goods, services and jobs than in automobile-dependent spawl, and that Atlanta (Pisarski's example of an automobile-dependent city) is no more economically successful than more multi-modal cities.

Let me add some hard data to this debate. The figure below shows the relationship between per capita vehicle travel and GDP for major U.S. urban regions. It indicates that regions where people drive less tend to be more economically productive.

 

Figure 1 Per Capita GDP and VMT For U.S. States

Per capita economic productivity increases as vehicle travel declines. (Each dot is a U.S. state.)

 

 

Figure 2 shows the relationship between roadway lane miles and GDP. It indicates that regions with less roadway supply tend to be more economically productive.

 

Figure 2          Per Capita Road Lane Miles and GDP

Economic productivity declines with more roadway supply, an indicator of automobile-oriented transport and land use patterns. (Each dot is a U.S. urban region.)

  

Figure 3 shows the relationship between per capita transit ridership and GDP. It indicates that regions with higher transit ridership tend to be more economically productive.

 Figure 3          Per Capita GDP and Transit Ridership

GDP tends to increase with per capita transit travel. (Each dot is a U.S. urban region.)

 

There is plenty of econmic theory to support the conclusion that multi-modal transportation systems support economic development more than automobile dependent transport systems. Travel demands are diverse: some goods and activities are accessed most efficiently by automobile, but others are most efficiently accessed by walking, cycling or public transit. As a result, an efficient transport system supports diverse mobility options and gives travelers incentives to use the most efficient mode for each trip, through efficient pricing of roads, parking, insurance and fuel.

Like most economic imputs, roadway investments can have deminishing marginal benefits. Although the first highways built in a region tend to provide large productivity benefits, once the basic roadway system exists, further expansion provides less incremental benefit. Figure 4 illustrates the result of a U.S. Federal Highway Administration study which indicates that, although highway construction provided very high return on investment during the 1950s and 60s, when the Interstate Highway System was connecting regions, economic returns subsequently declined, because the most productive projects (those linking regions) had been completed, leaving less productive links to be added.

Although that analysis did not continue to the following decades, it is likely that economic returns from highway expansion continued to decline.

 

Figure 4          Annual Highway Rate of Return (Nadri and Mamuneas 1996)

Highway investment economic returns were high during the 1950s and 60s when the U.S. Interstate was first developed, but have since declined, and are now probably below the returns on private capital, suggesting that highway expansion is generally a poor investment.

 

Automobile transportation is costly to governments (for roads), businesses (for parkling subsidies), consumers (to own and operate automobiles), and economies (to import vehicles and fuel). These are true resource costs which burden an economy. Automobile-dependent transport systems are particularly harmful to physically, economically and socially disadvantaged people who either cannot drive, or are significantly burdened by the financial costs of driving.

This is not to suggest that automobile transportation should be eliminated altogether, but it does indicate that transport policies that create more diverse and resource efficient transport systems do more to support economic development, provide more consumer benefit, and provide more economic opportunity to disadvantaged people than further highway expansion.

 

For More Information

Marlon Boarnet (1997), "New Highways & Economic Productivity: Interpreting Recent Evidence," Journal of Planning Literature, Vol. 11, No. 4, May 1997, pp. 476-486; also available as Working Paper 291, University of California Transportation Center, www.uctc.net/papers/291.pdf.

David J. Forkenbrock and Glen E. Weisbrod (2001), Guidebook for Assessing the Social and Economic Effects of Transportation Projects, NCHRP Report 456, Transportation Research Board, National Academy Press (www.trb.org).

Piyapong Jiwattanakulpaisarn, Robert B. Noland, Daniel J. Graham and John W. Polak (2009), "Highway Infrastructure And State-Level Employment: A Causal Spatial Analysis," Papers in Regional Science, Volume 88 Number 1, pp. 133 – 159; at http://ideas.repec.org/a/eee/transa/v44y2010i4p265-280.html.

Andreas Kopp (2006), Macroeconomic Productivity Effects of Road Investment: A Reassessment for Western Europe, Transportation Research Board 85th Annual Meeting (www.trb.org); available at www.mdt.mt.gov/research/docs/trb_cd/Files/06-2210.pdf.

Todd Litman (2009), Are Vehicle Travel Reduction Targets Justified? Evaluating Mobility Management Policy Objectives Such As Targets To Reduce VMT And Increase Use Of Alternative Modes, VTPI (www.vtpi.org); at www.vtpi.org/vmt_red.pdf.

Todd Litman (2010), Evaluating Transportation Economic Development Impacts, VTPI (www.vtpi.org); at www.vtpi.org/econ_dev.pdf.

SACTRA (1999), A Framework for Assessing Studies of the Impact of Transport Infrastructure Projects on Economic Activity, Standing Advisory Committee on Trunk Road Assessment, Dept. of Environment, Transport and Regions (www.roads.detr.gov.uk); available at www.dft.gov.uk/stellent/groups/dft_transstrat/documents/page/dft_transstrat_504940.pdf.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Todd Litman

Todd Litman is founder and executive director of the Victoria Transport Policy Institute, an independent research organization dedicated to developing innovative solutions to transport problems. His work helps to expand the range of impacts and options considered in transportation decision-making, improve evaluation methods, and make specialized technical concepts accessible to a larger audience. His research is used worldwide in transport planning and policy analysis.

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Cover CM Credits, Earn Certificates, Push Your Career Forward

Aerial view of town of Wailuku in Maui, Hawaii with mountains in background against cloudy sunset sky.

Maui's Vacation Rental Debate Turns Ugly

Verbal attacks, misinformation campaigns and fistfights plague a high-stakes debate to convert thousands of vacation rentals into long-term housing.

July 1, 2025 - Honolulu Civil Beat

Logo for Planetizen Federal Action Tracker with black and white image of U.S. Capitol with water ripple overlay.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

July 9, 2025 - Diana Ionescu

Map of Haussmann's redesign of Paris in the 1850s through 1870s under Napoleon III.

In Urban Planning, AI Prompting Could be the New Design Thinking

Creativity has long been key to great urban design. What if we see AI as our new creative partner?

June 30, 2025 - Tom Sanchez

Adult holding hands of two children, all wearing winter coats, in crosswalk in New York City during holidays with trees decorated with lights in background.

Pedestrian Deaths Drop, Remain Twice as High as in 2009

Fatalities declined by 4 percent in 2024, but the U.S. is still nowhere close to ‘Vision Zero.’

30 minutes ago - Streetsblog USA

View of dense apartment buildings on Seattle waterfront with high-rise buildings in background.

King County Supportive Housing Program Offers Hope for Unhoused Residents

The county is taking a ‘Housing First’ approach that prioritizes getting people into housing, then offering wraparound supportive services.

July 11 - Real Change

Aerial view of suburban housing near Las Vegas, Nevada.

Researchers Use AI to Get Clearer Picture of US Housing

Analysts are using artificial intelligence to supercharge their research by allowing them to comb through data faster. Though these AI tools can be error prone, they save time and housing researchers are optimistic about the future.

July 11 - Shelterforce Magazine