The Orthodoxy of Urbanism
Planners take a prescriptive approach to urbanism, while people have their own ideas about what makes good places that don't fit the standard orthodoxy. Drew Austin says both extremes need attention, and synthesis.
Austin compares the two approaches to theories of language, Prescriptivism and Descriptivism:
"Prescriptivists are those who believe in objective, fixed rules to guide the usage of language; Descriptivists, on the other hand, seek to define a language by how people actually use it."
Planners have a tendency to develop a prescriptivist set of beliefs and approaches:
"Density, mixed-use development, and transit become components of an urbanist orthodoxy; a freeway through a vibrant neighborhood troubles the urban Prescriptivist in the same way an 'ain't' irks the English teacher."
Published on Tuesday, April 20, 2010 in
Topics
- Google's San Jose Transit Village Plans Revealed
- The Varied Career of a Transit Service Planner
- The Life and Death of Neighborhood Rebrandings
- 150 Acres of Undeveloped Land to Become 2,350 Homes Outside Denver
- City to Bicyclists: Berkeley Not in Idaho
- Anti-Development Forces Strike at L.A.'s Transit Oriented Communities Program
- New York City 'More Congested Than Ever'
- Kanye West's Unpermitted Vision for Housing Utopia Has Been Demolished
- What Walk Buttons Do (and Don't Do)
- Jersey City Building More Apartment Than Manhattan
- 28.3 Million Acres of Public Land at Risk in Alaska
- First-Time Home Buyers Look Different Than They Once Did
- Consumer Group Accuses States of 'Punishing' Electric Vehicle Drivers
- L.A.'s New Tool for More Efficient City Asset Management
- Pedestrian Planning Changing the Public Realm in Vancouver
- Digital Transportation: The Future of Urban Mobility
- Frequencies Restored on L.A.'s Expo Line After Rider Backlash
- A Traffic Safety Commitment for Chicago's West Side
- Report: Shared Bikes and Scooters Could Reduce Car Trips By 50 Percent in Downtowns
- The Great Flood of 2019, Visualized
