Pandemic Endgame: Redefining the Herd Immunity Goal

So much for vaccines enabling the U.S. to achieve the cherished goal of herd immunity for COVID-19. It is becoming increasingly clear to many public health experts that likely will not happen, according to a New York Times global health reporter.

4 minute read

May 4, 2021, 12:00 PM PDT

By Irvin Dawid


COVID-19 Pandemic

Olga Mukashev / Shutterstock

Two months ago many experts likened the U.S. position in the pandemic to a battle between virus variants and vaccines, as if one would emerge a winner. Mandavilli writes that a new consensus is emerging, one that entails living with the virus.

It is already clear, however, that the virus is changing too quickly, new variants are spreading too easily and vaccination is proceeding too slowly for herd immunity to be within reach anytime soon.

“The virus is unlikely to go away,” said Rustom Antia, an evolutionary biologist at Emory University in Atlanta. “But we want to do all we can to check that it’s likely to become a mild infection.”

Politico supported the endemic end game scenario in an article framing the pandemic challenge facing President Joe Biden in his next 100 days published just a few days before the Times' piece.

"[C]ontainment, not eradication, is the most realistic goal: Public health experts say the coronavirus is here for the long haul," wrote health care reporter, Dan Goldberg, and health care editor, Joanne Kenen on April 30.

Now, the challenge for Biden, his response team and state health officials will be managing the rolling series of outbreaks possibly driven by more dangerous virus variants, while avoiding the wishful thinking of the Trump administration, which downplayed the disease's lethality.

Not all experts agree

Dr. Ashish Jha, dean of the Brown University School of Public Health, expressed some skepticism on the notion that herd immunity is not achievable.

"We don't know if it's true," he told CNN New Day hosts John Berman and Brianna Keilar on May 3, but he did acknowledge that it would be "unfortunate" if the country weren't to reach herd immunity levels.

"At herd immunity levels, you really don't have to have any restrictions at all and the virus remains in check," said Jha.

"But that said, the experience from Israel is that once you get to about 50-55% of the population vaccinated, which a few states have now hit in the U.S., you really see case numbers plummet. So we may not get to zero, we probably won't, but if we can get infections under very low levels, most of us can get back to our lives in normal ways. I think we can probably live with that.

"With around 60 percent of its population vaccinated, Israel has managed to almost fully reopen its economy and crush the number of coronavirus cases and deaths to nearly zero," wrote  for Vox in an endgame article referencing Mandavilli's piece.

The country still has some requirements in place — particularly indoor masking and vaccine passport requirements — but it’s much closer to normal than it could afford to be, with any guarantee of safety, just months ago.

Fauci gets last word

The nation's foremost public health expert, Dr. Anthony Fauci, appeared to agree with Jha.

“People were getting confused and thinking you’re never going to get the infections down until you reach this mystical level of herd immunity, whatever that number is,” he told Mandavilli.

“That’s why we stopped using herd immunity in the classic sense,” he added. “I’m saying: Forget that for a second. You vaccinate enough people, the infections are going to go down."

Related in Planetizen:

Monday, May 3, 2021 in The New York Times

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Use Code 25for25 at checkout for 25% off an annual plan!

Redlining map of Oakland and Berkeley.

Rethinking Redlining

For decades we have blamed 100-year-old maps for the patterns of spatial racial inequity that persist in American cities today. An esteemed researcher says: we’ve got it all wrong.

May 15, 2025 - Alan Mallach

Logo for Planetizen Federal Action Tracker with black and white image of U.S. Capitol with water ripple overlay.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

May 14, 2025 - Diana Ionescu

Front of Walmart store with sign.

Walmart Announces Nationwide EV Charging Network

The company plans to install electric car chargers at most of its stores by 2030.

May 7, 2025 - Inc.

Aerial view of Albuquerque, New Mexico at sunset.

New State Study Suggests Homelessness Far Undercounted in New Mexico

An analysis of hospital visit records provided a more accurate count than the annual point-in-time count used by most agencies.

May 16 - Source NM

Close-up on white bike helmet lying on pavement with blurred red bike on its side in background abd black car visible behind it.

Michigan Bills Would Stiffen Penalties for Deadly Crashes

Proposed state legislation would close a ‘legal gap’ that lets drivers who kill get away with few repercussions.

May 16 - Wood TV 8

Muni bus on red painted bus-only lane in downtown San Francisco, California.

Report: Bus Ridership Back to 86 Percent of Pre-Covid Levels

Transit ridership around the country was up by 85 percent in all modes in 2024.

May 16 - Mass Transit