What Went Wrong With Oregon's Climate Bill?

The Oregon Climate Action Program, which would have priced carbon emissions by establishing a cap-and-trade program similar to the one in California, was defeated on Saturday, the penultimate day of the 2019 legislative session.

4 minute read

July 2, 2019, 9:00 AM PDT

By Irvin Dawid

Portland, Oregon

JPL Designs / Shutterstock

The Oregon legislature made history this session, which ended Sunday, by outlawing single-family zoning and making life easier for bicyclists by allowing them to treat stop signs like yield signs, but was unable to pass a critical climate bill despite having supermajority control of both chambers.

"This was the year for Oregon to enact the nation’s second economy-wide cap on greenhouse gases and reclaim her national environmental bona fides. Even Republicans acknowledged the inevitability," writes Ted Sickinger, an investigative reporter who has been chronicling the effort for The Oregonian, on June 30.

Democrats had a [three-fifths] supermajority in both houses. The governor, House Speaker and Senate President were all on board.

While that margin exceeded the supermajority requirement for bills that raise taxes, it was not clear whether that threshold was needed. In the end, it wouldn't matter when the bill reached the Senate.

"House Bill 2020 [which establishes the Oregon Climate Action Program] is one of the most complex and sprawling pieces of legislation ever to come before Oregon lawmakers, wrote Sickinger on June 17 after the bill passed the House on a 36-to-24 vote. 

It envisions a wholesale reduction in Oregonians’ use of fossil fuels, and an associated decrease in greenhouse gas emissions equivalent to 80 percent below 1990 levels by 2050.

Republican walkout

The national media was captivated when Democratic Gov. Kate Brown authorized the Oregon State Police on June 20 "to retrieve the [11] Senate Republicans, who fled the Capitol in order to deprive the Senate of a quorum and block the likely passage of the carbon-reduction legislation," as reported by Nigel Jaquiss of Willamette Week.

However, Senate President Peter Courtney conceded on June 25 that there was disunity within Democratic ranks that would prevent the bill's passage, which led to the return of most of the Republican senators on Saturday after being on the lam for nine days. 

 "When Courtney banged down his gavel on the 17-10 vote [on Saturday], the biggest controversy of the 2019 session was over," reported Jaquiss on June 29. House Bill 2020 had died, and with it the opportunity for Oregon to join California, Quebec and Nova Scotia in the Western Climate Initiative.

What went wrong

"Democrats needed support from 16 of the 18 members of their Senate caucus in order to pass it," reported Sickinger and his colleagues on June 26 after Sen. Courtney divulged the bad news for supporters. Three Democrats were holdouts, some representing "districts where major employers were particularly opposed to the climate bill." Another issue that concerned lawmakers – the effect of the bill on gas and diesel prices.

Sickinger goes on to do an extensive political postmortem on the "complex 180-page bill, one that eventually had more than 100 proposed amendments." 

Rewriting it to incorporate the first major round of changes – including deals Democrats cut with specific industries and interest groups -- took weeks. And in the end, the bill didn’t land for a final vote in the Senate until 11 days [June 19] before the constitutionally mandated close of the session.

A major point Sickinger makes is the urban-rural divide on climate policy, particularly when it comes to carbon pricing. A map of the districts of the 11 senators who walked-out makes that divide very clear, as its the overwhelming majority of the state, geographically speaking. [Scroll down to the image below "Republican senators’ districts" in the June 26 Oregonian article].

But outside the metro area, the concerns are real, rooted in past experience and the feeling that urban architects of the policy don’t truly care about the consequences on their way of life.

The coalition of supporters [including Renew Oregon] never had an effective spokesperson to counter that. It certainly wasn’t Gov. Kate Brown, who is not popular in rural reaches of the state. And not a single Republican lawmaker representing those districts took up the mantle.

However, the political divide between Republicans and Democrats exceeds the urban-rural split, according to a researcher cited by Sickinger.

Additional reading: "Cap and trade: What could Oregon’s carbon policy cost you?" June 19: Sickinger explains how the program would hike prices, particularly on transportation fuel.

“The bill makes the urban-rural divide stronger than ever because the biggest polluters are in Oregon’s large cities,” said Senate Republican Leader Herman Baertschiger, Jr., R-Grants Pass. “It is fundamentally inequitable to put the responsibility of cleaning up their pollution on the backs of rural Oregonians.”

Update from Associated Press, July 1: Gov. Kate Brown indicated she's prepared to use her executive power to have Oregon initiate the carbon cap-and-trade program by directing her staff to work with opponents in the rural parts of the state who were key to defeating the bill in the Senate, reports Sarah Zimmerman.

"Working on legislation is my preferred approach," she told reporters. "However, given the uncertainty that now permeates Oregon's political system, I am also directing my staff and agencies to explore alternative paths."

Related in Planetizen:

Sunday, June 30, 2019 in The Oregonian

Single-family homes in a suburban neighborhood in Florida.

New Florida Law Curbs HOA Power

The legislation seeks to cut down on ‘absurd’ citations for low-level violations.

June 16, 2024 - The Guardian

Multistory apartment building under construction.

New Tennessee Law Allows No-Cost Incentives for Affordable Housing

Local governments in the Volunteer State can now offer developers incentives like increased density, lower parking requirements, and priority permitting for affordable housing projects.

June 10, 2024 - Nooga Today

Aerial view of intersection in New York City with yellow cabs and zebra crosswalks.

Planners’ Complicity in Excessive Traffic Deaths

Professor Wes Marshall’s provocatively-titled new book, "Killed by a Traffic Engineer," has stimulated fierce debates. Are his criticisms justified? Let’s examine the degree that traffic engineers contribute to avoidable traffic deaths.

June 13, 2024 - Todd Litman

Bike parking in underground area with ramp for taking bikes upstairs.

California Building Code to Add Bike Parking Requirements

Convenient and secure bike parking can make a major impact on whether people adopt biking as a daily transportation option.

3 hours ago - Streetsblog California

Close-up on map of Kemmerer, Wyoming.

Nation's First Nuclear Power Plant in Nearly Half a Century Breaks Ground in Wyoming

Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates had shovel-in-hand for the groundbreaking of his company's small-scale nuclear power plant in Kemmerer, Wyoming, on June 10.

4 hours ago - WyoFile

Close-up of red Houston BCycle bike share bikes parked at a station

Houston Will Be Largest US City Without Bike Share

The city’s bike share system will cease operations at the end of June.

5 hours ago - Houston Public Media

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.