Planetizen - Urban Planning News, Jobs, and Education

Houston's Drainage Problem

Houston received over 50 inches of rain from Hurricane Harvey in five days. While no city could survive that drenching unscathed, Houston was not prepared to handle the floods due to decades of neglect of stormwater management planning.
August 31, 2017, 10am PDT | Irvin Dawid
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email Comments
Houston Flood
Jill Carlson

"[P]eople care about flooding, because it’s dramatic and catastrophic," writes Ian Bogosta contributing editor at The Atlantic in an in depth article on the flooding that Houston is experiencing since Aug. 25 due to Hurricane Harvey"They don’t care about stormwater management, which is where the real issue lies."

Houston poses both a typical and an unusual situation for stormwater management. The city is enormous, stretching out over 600 square miles. It’s an epitome of the urban sprawl characterized by American exurbanism, where available land made development easy at the edges.

Unlike New Orleans, Houston is well above sea level, so flooding risk from storm surge inundation is low. Instead, it’s rainfall that poses the biggest threat.

"Houston is the most flood-prone city in the United States," said Rice University environmental engineering professor Phil Bedient, in an article by the Associated Press on the city's "obsolete drainage grid." "No one is even a close second — not even New Orleans, because at least they have pumps there."

Bogost offers two different approaches to stormwater management. Once focuses on decreasing impervious surfaces [also see Michael Lewyn's blog post on Aug. 30].

Many planners contend that impervious surface itself is the problem. The more of it there is, the less absorption takes place and the more runoff has to be managed. Reducing development, then, is one of the best ways to manage urban flooding. The problem is, urban development hasn’t slowed in the last half-century. 

But Thomas Debo, an emeritus professor of city planning at Georgia Tech who also wrote a popular textbook on stormwater management, takes issue with pavement reduction as a viable cure for urban flooding.

“We focus too much on impervious surface and not enough on the conveyance of water,” he tells me. Even when reduced in quantity, the water still ends up in in pipes and concrete channels, speeding fast toward larger channels. “It’s like taking an aspirin to cure an ailment,” he scoffs. Houston’s flooding demonstrates the impact.

Water conveyance was built into Houston drainage plan. It supplements the "slow-moving rivers, called bayous, (that) provide natural drainage for the area," writes Bogost.

To account for the certainty of flooding, Houston has built drainage channels, sewers, outfalls, on- and off-road ditches, and detention ponds to hold or move water away from local areas. When they fill, the roadways provide overrun. The dramatic images from Houston that show wide, interstate freeways transformed into rivers look like the cause of the disaster, but they are also its solution, if not an ideal one.

And this approach vindicates Houston Mayor Sylvester Turner's decision to not call for a mandatory evacuation, which many have questioned.

This is also why evacuating Houston, a metropolitan area of 6.5 million people, would have been a terrible idea. This is a city run by cars, and sending its residents to sit in gridlock on the thoroughfares and freeways designed to become rivers during flooding would have doomed them to death by water.

Vox's science reporter, Brian Resnick, also investigated Houston's flood-prone geography, and interviewed Rice's Phil Bedient as well. He offered several reasons why the flooding was so severe, among them, urban sprawl contributing to a lack of impervious spaces due to concreting the landscape. Resnick also cited another reason to vindicate Mayor Turner's non-evacuation decision.

In 2005 Houston issued an evacuation order for 2.5 million people for Hurricane Rita. It was chaotic: More than 100 people died while evacuating. People were stuck on the roadways for days.

As of Aug. 30, the death toll from Hurricane Harvey is 30 people. Harvey has made a second landfall and is wreaking havoc in Port Arthur and Beaumont, Texas, as it did Houston.

Share Tweet LinkedIn Email