The Roots of Racial Transition

In some American cities, the white population is growing while the black population is declining. Is this a result of gentrification or of black upward mobility?

2 minute read

July 17, 2017, 9:00 AM PDT

By Michael Lewyn @mlewyn


Uptown Oakland

cdrin / Shutterstock

In a recent blog post, one of my favorite urban affairs bloggers, Pete Saunders, writes in that eight of the 20 largest American urbanized areas (Los Angeles,Chicago, Detroit, San Francisco, Seattle,Tampa, Baltimore, St. Louis), the central city's white population grew while the central city's black population declined. And in all but two of these (Los Angeles and San Francisco) the black population grew in suburbia.

It seems to me that there are two possible interpretations of this data:

*The "Gentrification/Displacement Story." According to this story, because blacks tend to be poorer than whites, they tend to be priced out of central cities, and are being forced into cheaper suburbs.

*The "Upward Mobility Story." According to this story (which Saunders seems to prefer), black suburbanization is evidence of affluence rather than poverty. As middle-class blacks are gaining wealth, they are leaving decaying urban neighborhoods for the relative safety of suburbia.

So how can we figure out which story is closer to reality?

It seems to me that if the first story is true, the blacks leaving cities would tend to be the poorest, while better-off blacks get to stay. Thus, central city poverty rates would have declined in recent years. By contrast, if the second story is true, we would see higher rates of black poverty in the central cities, as better-off blacks moved to suburbia. 

In all six cities* where black suburbanization was most pronounced (that is, where black urban population declined, white urban population did not, and black suburban population grew) black poverty grew between 2012 and 2015. Sometimes, the rise was not statistically significant – for example, in Baltimore, the black urban poverty rate rose from 27.2% to 28.1%.** Similarly, in St. Louis the black poverty rate grew from 37.7% to 38.1%. On the other hand, in Seattle, the black poverty rate grew from 28.5% to 33.6%, the largest increase among these six cities. By contrast, white poverty rates were stable in all six cities—in all but Detroit, the poverty rate grew or declined by less than 1 point. (In Detroit it rose from 37.3% to 39.6%.) In all of these cities, poverty rates for both racial groups were lower in 1999, reflecting (I suspect) the Great Recession.

So to the extent the evidence tells any story at all, it suggests that blacks moving to the suburbs were middle-class (or at least nonpoor)—which in turn suggests that black migration in these places might be a result of upward mobility rather than gentrification-related displacement.

*That is, the eight cities mentioned at the start of this post, minus Los Angeles and San Francisco. 

*The data supporting this discussion is here


Michael Lewyn

Michael Lewyn is a professor at Touro University, Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center, in Long Island. His scholarship can be found at http://works.bepress.com/lewyn.

courses user

As someone new to the planning field, Planetizen has been the perfect host guiding me into planning and our complex modern challenges. Corey D, Transportation Planner

As someone new to the planning field, Planetizen has been the perfect host guiding me into planning and our complex modern challenges.

Corey D, Transportation Planner

Ready to give your planning career a boost?

View of dense apartment buildings on Seattle waterfront with high-rise buildings in background.

Seattle Legalizes Co-Living

A new state law requires all Washington cities to allow co-living facilities in areas zoned for multifamily housing.

December 1, 2024 - Smart Cities Dive

Times Square in New York City empty during the Covid-19 pandemic.

NYC Officials Announce Broadway Pedestrianization Project

Two blocks of the marquee street will become mostly car-free public spaces.

December 1, 2024 - StreetsBlog NYC

'Vertical canyon' on glass-clad residential high-rise in Denver, CO.

Denver's New High-Rise Integrates Vertical Canyon in Architectural Design

Unlike other new builds in Denver, Colorado, a new high-rise reveals a unique “sculptural canyon” running vertically through the facade to foster a sense of community and connection to nature.  

November 29, 2024 - designboom

Close-up of black electric bike with person resting one foot on ground and holding blue helmet.

California E-Bike Rebate Program Launches — Again

After a series of fits and starts, CARB says the program will begin accepting applications this month.

December 5 - Streetsblog California

Vintage multi-story brick apartment building and modern concrete and glass apartment building separated by a steep public stairway in Los Angeles, California.

Analysis: Localized Upzoning Less Effective

Changing zoning rules for a small number of parcels can increase land values and housing costs without boosting the housing supply.

December 5 - Governing

Acela Amtrak train in station in New Haven, Connecticut.

Amtrak Breaks Ridership Record in FY 2024

More Americans than ever rode the rails last year, also bringing the agency its highest ticket revenue.

December 5 - Smart Cities Dive

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.

Write for Planetizen