Public Process and the Perils of Dismissive Engagement
Steve Jobs said, "People don’t know what they want until you show it to them.” So why do planners keep asking people what they'd like to see? Scott Doyon believes it's time to dig deeper.
Like product designers, urban planners and designers shouldn't be order takers. They need to be more like psychotherapists, seeking the underlying motivations for the things people ask for. Scott Doyon explains:
“'What would you like to see here?'”
"And there it is. Perhaps the most inane question ever posed in the course of a public design process. And posed it is, constantly.
“'We’re doing a master plan for downtown. What would you like to see here?'”
"It’s crazy. In one sweeping question, practitioners not only set the stage for unmet expectations, they devalue the art and craft of urban design at the same time."
Published on Thursday, January 24, 2013 in
Topics
- Friday Funny: The Onion Eviscerates Bike Planning
- Planning for Crime Reduction
- $1.5 Billion in BUILD Grants Announced
- Where Campus Planning Meets Urban Planning
- When Cities Prosper, Rural Areas Are Better Off
- All of L.A.'s Rail Lines Will Get New Names
- Thumbs Down to Planning Rules of Thumb
- Putting a Bow on Top of the Minneapolis 2040 Comprehensive Plan
- Suburbs Encouraging Accessory Dwelling Units
- Public Transportation Is Good for Kids
- Western Planner Articles Published Since 1980 Now Available Online for Free
- California Fire Chief: Consider Ending Development in Fire Prone Areas
- Arlington County Updates Bike Plan
- Twin Cities Set Ambitious Target for Electric Buses
- The Future of the Retail Landscape
- The Sweet Smell of Density? Subconscious Influences on Perceptions of Urban Form
- Construction Contracts Awarded for Chicago Transit Authority's Largest Project Ever
- D.C. Council Chooses Commercial Property Tax Breaks Over Homeless Funding
- Penalties for Fare Evasion Not a Good Look
- Songs About Places - 2018
