Labeling the Gas Tax
The gas tax should be viewed as that, a tax, and anything else is fundamentally wrong, writes Alex Marshall.
Marshall says a gas tax should not be considered a user fee because unlike a tax, a user fee gives the consumer a choice to either pay, or not to pay. He sites the fee to enter and park at a national park, as well as the use of toll roads as examples that incur user fees. People have the choice to pay to park, or to use the less traveled tollway.
"To qualify as a user fee, you must have a choice as to whether or not you pay it. It also must relate directly to a particular service that you can accept or reject, and to the number of times you use that service."
Marshall adds,
"Why do all these labels matter? Aren't they just semantics? No, because labels influence policies."
Full Story:
Published on Tuesday, April 5, 2011 in
- Report: No City or State in the U.S. Has Enough Housing for Low-Income Residents
- Scooter Media Brief: Safety, Security, and Business Models Raise Concerns
- The New New Protected Bike Lane
- Trump's Budget Would Cut Funding for HUD, Transportation, EPA, More
- 3D Printing Affordable Housing at Scale
- Editorial: Raise Height Limits to San Jose's Proper Stature
- U.S. Risks Becoming Backwater for Electric Vehicle Sales
- It Takes a Fatality to Remove On-Street Parking
- Five Years of 100 Resilient Cities
- Where Gas Taxes Only Serve the Needs of More Sprawl
- Bus Transit Used to Be Profitable on the Las Vegas Strip
- Study: Density Can Impede Growth
- Climate Resilience Plan Would Extend Manhattan
- Deadly Flooding Follows Bomb Cyclone in the Midwest
- Many Norms, Few Plans: Urban Rubble Clearance in the Cities of the Global South
- Home Builders Aren't Building the Smaller Homes the Market Wants
- An App for Finding the Best Ground Transportation Options at Airports
- New Leadership at SPUR
- An App That Maps Safer Cities for Women
- Concrete’s Contribution to the Rise and Decline of Civilization
