post-Starbucks planning

Starbucks stores have seen a lot of protests. Due to its international brand recognition, the chain became an easy mark for activists looking to draw media attention to concerns from genetic engineering to union busting, from store placements in historically sensitive locations to the company’s opposition to Ethiopia’s application to trademark three types of coffee.

4 minute read

September 16, 2008, 7:56 AM PDT

By Jess Zimbabwe


Starbucks
stores have seen a lot of protests. Due to its international brand recognition,
the chain became an easy mark for activists looking to draw media attention to
concerns from genetic
engineering
to union busting,
from store placements in
historically sensitive locations
to the
company's opposition to Ethiopia's application to trademark three types of
coffee
. Citizens, activists, and planners engaged zoning overlays,
preservation districts, and other tools of local planning in dozens if not
hundreds of cities and towns where residents bemoaned the chain's role in the erosion
of unique local character. Starbucks' seemingly never-ending expansion was the
subject of ridicule
and satire. Starbucks
seemed like a never-ending font of ire and a butt of perpetual jokes.

That's
why I can't quite wrap my head around the grassroots (and quite sentimental) "save our starbucks"
movement that has emerged in response to announced plans to close around 600
stores
.

From
Newark
to Knoxville,
customers, city planners, neighborhood activists, and mayors are asking the
company to reconsider plans to close the locations. (Generally speaking, Starbucks
is not slating its airport locations for closure. These stores, rather than
being well-loved, are at least broadly considered a vast improvement over the
airport bars with scalded coffee and perma-stale Danish that they replaced.)

It
seems that Starbucks has come to represent progress for a neighborhood. Beyond initial
concerns that the stores would simply draw a more gentrified clientele, the
stores have become symbols for each neighborhood or city's appearance on the
international map, as if the threat of closure will send area residents and patrons
stumbling back into oblivion. The Starbucks stores move into a neighborhood as
the check-cashing businesses, the liquor and adult video stores, and the fried-food-through-bullet-proof-glass
stores move out. (Indeed, here's an
advertisement for the sale of a check-cashing business
that lists among its
unique attributes that it is located in the same shopping center as a Starbucks.)
Like the Guggenheim Museum was for Bilbao, Starbucks has symbolized the moment
of "arrival" for towns in plains states, long-downtrodden neighborhoods in rust
belt cities, and previously center-less suburbs of the Sunbelt states.

The
reasons for the Starbucks closures are varied. In some markets, Starbucks faces
stiff competition from locally
or regionally owned competitors
. In other parts of the country with low population,
analysts have surmised that the chain "expanded
before some markets were ready
." In several markets, Starbucks faces
heightened competition from other international chains like Dunkin' Donuts (who
has designed a new
store prototype
with fancier finishes).

There
has been a small, but growing realization for several years Starbucks may not
be all bad for local businesses. Indeed, independently owned coffee shops have
seen exceptionally good business in the past five years, nationwide. A lot of
this is due to Starbucks' success at bringing an Italian-originated coffee bar
culture to the U.S. (When Howard Schultz became President & CEO of Starbucks
in 1987, he travelled to Italy and was enraptured by the jovial atmosphere of
Italy's espresso bars. He exported the concept of coffee shop as social space,
created a franchise-able interior decoration scheme that complemented the
concept, and hired skilled real estate experts to lead the charge of spreading
the stores across the land.) In 2007, Slate's
Taylor Clark spoke with a former
Starbucks real estate specialist
and concluded that despite the growth of
independently-owned coffee shops, "Starbucks is actually trying to be ruthless in
its store placements; it wants those independents out of the way, and it
frequently succeeds at displacing them through other means, such as buying a
mom and pop's lease or intimidating them into selling out."

Local
planners and their booster allies shouldn't shed too many tears about a
Starbucks closure or two (or even 13 as proposed in Las Vegas). The company,
like so many others, found a good thing in rapid expansion plans and then
failed to correctly identify when the trend had ended before they had over-extended
and their competition had learned the lessons as well. Planners should rise
above the "responding" level and examine behaviors in the areas that are losing
Starbucks to identify the next trends. Maybe it's another coffee shop. Perhaps
there is even room to learn from Architect Magazine's design competition
for a "Starbucks of the Future."
Study up on trends research like that on mobility hubs
coming out of Center for Advancing Research and Solutions for Society at the
University of Michigan. And if you still feel sentimental about losing the
Starbucks, maybe you can meet up with this guy for part of his
ambitious journey to visit every Starbucks in the world.


Jess Zimbabwe

Jess Zimbabwe is Executive Director of Environmental Works Community Design Center in Seattle, a nonprofit that plans, designs, and advocates for community-centered environments. Previously, she founded the consulting practice Plot Strategies and served as the founding Director of the Daniel Rose Center for Public Leadership, a partnership of the National League of Cities and the Urban Land Institute. Earlier, she led the Mayors’ Institute on City Design and was Community Design Director at Urban Ecology in Oakland.

"Planetizen federal action tracker" logo superimposed over black and white image of US Capitol dome.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

November 11, 2026 - Zachary Whalen

A highway in Washington state.

Washington state to charge fee to drivers with fuel-efficient cars

Revenue from the fee will go towards supporting the state’s highways.

November 17, 2026 - The Urbanist

People walking and cycling on a street in Boston.

Study reveals best places in the U.S. for cycling, walking

New research from Streetlight Data examines bicycle and pedestrian miles per capita in the 100 largest U.S. cities by population.

November 8, 2026 - Smart Cities Dive

A rendering of the project which shows two bus lanes side by side with a passenger island in the middle of the road

Mamdani unveils his ‘most ambitious bus lane project’ so far

The city has added two new bus lanes, which it expects to speed up tens of thousands of bus riders’ commutes.

6 hours ago - Gothamist

new Yorker's cross the street next to bus

New Jersey and New York suggest $10.3 billion budget for transit

Some of the budget is dedicated to replacing Manhattan's Midtown Bus Terminal.

7 hours ago - Future Transport

Aerial view of Kingston power plant in Roane County, Tennessee

States split over EPA’s proposal to drop greenhouse gas rules for power plants

The proposed rule drew over 165K comments, including from officials, health and environmental groups, and private citizens.

November 18 - Stateline

FREE Course: Walkable City 1: Why Walkability?

After describing his path towards focusing on walkability as the essence of good planning, Jeff Speck marches through his five principal reasons for making more walkable places.

Reinventing Malls: Planning Alchemy—Turning Gray Fields Into Gold

The course focuses on the opportunities and imperatives that shape reinvention of mall sites.

Write for Planetizen