Pandemic Endgame: Redefining the Herd Immunity Goal

So much for vaccines enabling the U.S. to achieve the cherished goal of herd immunity for COVID-19. It is becoming increasingly clear to many public health experts that likely will not happen, according to a New York Times global health reporter.

May 4, 2021, 12:00 PM PDT

By Irvin Dawid


COVID-19 Pandemic

Olga Mukashev / Shutterstock

Two months ago many experts likened the U.S. position in the pandemic to a battle between virus variants and vaccines, as if one would emerge a winner. Mandavilli writes that a new consensus is emerging, one that entails living with the virus.

It is already clear, however, that the virus is changing too quickly, new variants are spreading too easily and vaccination is proceeding too slowly for herd immunity to be within reach anytime soon.

“The virus is unlikely to go away,” said Rustom Antia, an evolutionary biologist at Emory University in Atlanta. “But we want to do all we can to check that it’s likely to become a mild infection.”

Politico supported the endemic end game scenario in an article framing the pandemic challenge facing President Joe Biden in his next 100 days published just a few days before the Times' piece.

"[C]ontainment, not eradication, is the most realistic goal: Public health experts say the coronavirus is here for the long haul," wrote health care reporter, Dan Goldberg, and health care editor, Joanne Kenen on April 30.

Now, the challenge for Biden, his response team and state health officials will be managing the rolling series of outbreaks possibly driven by more dangerous virus variants, while avoiding the wishful thinking of the Trump administration, which downplayed the disease's lethality.

Not all experts agree

Dr. Ashish Jha, dean of the Brown University School of Public Health, expressed some skepticism on the notion that herd immunity is not achievable.

"We don't know if it's true," he told CNN New Day hosts John Berman and Brianna Keilar on May 3, but he did acknowledge that it would be "unfortunate" if the country weren't to reach herd immunity levels.

"At herd immunity levels, you really don't have to have any restrictions at all and the virus remains in check," said Jha.

"But that said, the experience from Israel is that once you get to about 50-55% of the population vaccinated, which a few states have now hit in the U.S., you really see case numbers plummet. So we may not get to zero, we probably won't, but if we can get infections under very low levels, most of us can get back to our lives in normal ways. I think we can probably live with that.

"With around 60 percent of its population vaccinated, Israel has managed to almost fully reopen its economy and crush the number of coronavirus cases and deaths to nearly zero," wrote  for Vox in an endgame article referencing Mandavilli's piece.

The country still has some requirements in place — particularly indoor masking and vaccine passport requirements — but it’s much closer to normal than it could afford to be, with any guarantee of safety, just months ago.

Fauci gets last word

The nation's foremost public health expert, Dr. Anthony Fauci, appeared to agree with Jha.

“People were getting confused and thinking you’re never going to get the infections down until you reach this mystical level of herd immunity, whatever that number is,” he told Mandavilli.

“That’s why we stopped using herd immunity in the classic sense,” he added. “I’m saying: Forget that for a second. You vaccinate enough people, the infections are going to go down."

Related in Planetizen:

Monday, May 3, 2021 in The New York Times

Chicago Commute

Planning for Congestion Relief

The third and final installment of Planetizen's examination of the role of the planning profession in both perpetuating and solving traffic congestion.

May 12, 2022 - James Brasuell

Twin Cities

Minneapolis Housing Plan a Success—Not for the Reason You Think

Housing advocates praise the city’s move to eliminate single-family zoning by legalizing triplexes on single-family lots, but that isn’t why housing construction is growing.

May 13, 2022 - Reason

Single-Family Housing Construction

New White House Housing Initiative Includes Zoning Reform Incentives

The Biden administration this morning released a new program of actions intended to spur housing construction around the United States.

May 16, 2022 - The White House

University of Arizona

Proposed Transit Line Would Connect Downtown Tucson to Airport

Based on community input for a 15-mile transit line, residents want to see a focus on affordable housing development and anti-displacement measures.

3 hours ago - KGUN

Shuttered strip mall in Niland, California

Strip Malls as a Housing Solution

The American strip mall may be a dying breed of commercial development, but could the buildings serve a new use as sustainable housing?

5 hours ago - Yale Environment 360

Complete Street Vancouver

Study: Most of Vancouver Is a ‘15-Minute City’

A large majority of Vancouver residents can access a grocery store in 15 minutes or less by bicycle or on foot.

May 20 - Vancouver Sun

HUD’s 2022 Innovative Housing Showcase

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Expanding HUD’s Eviction Protection Grant Program

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

New Updates on The Edge

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Hand Drawing Master Plans

This course aims to provide an introduction into Urban Design Sketching focused on how to hand draw master plans using a mix of colored markers.