All the coronavirus data is moving in the right direction in most of the U.S., yet 130,000 additional Americans are projected to die from COVID-19 by June according to one widely used model.
“Look, I told you before, I have a job...We’ve already lost over 450,000 people, and we’re going to lose a whole lot more if we don’t act and act decisively and quickly.”
As of Monday, the Covid death toll in the U.S. exceeded 486,000 people, according to data by Johns Hopkins University. "Another 130,000 Americans are projected to die of the virus over the next three and a half months, according to the latest model from the University of Washington's Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation, report Christina Maxouris and Dakin Andone for CNN on Feb. 14 (source article).
And while Covid-19 numbers may be trending in the right direction now, there are four key factors that will determine how the next few months unfold, the institute said in a briefing [pdf] accompanying its model.
But first – are the numbers trending in the right direction?
The seven-day rolling average of new coronavirus cases in the United States has declined 21% in the past week, according to The Washington Post tracker on Feb. 15, although the daily case incidence, 27 per 100,000 people, remains the highest among the eight regions listed on WaPo's global tracker. South America is second with 18 cases per 100k.
However, the real comparison is chronological—where the United States is within the pandemic that began just over 11 months ago. Last month was the deadliest, reported Whet Moser, a contributor to The Atlantic's Covid Tracking Project, on Feb. 2, "claiming more than 95,000 Americans, about one-fifth of the 433,751 deaths recorded-to-date."
The U.S. hit this mark even as the pandemic seems to be letting up, at least for now. Conditions have been improving since January 13, when the most reliable indicator of the coronavirus’s spread, hospitalizations, began a steady decline, from more than 130,000 to fewer than 95,000...But the seven-day average of daily deaths remains above 3,000, as it’s been almost every day since January 9. [The seven-day average is 2,541 on Feb. 15.]
February 7 was an important day in COVID data collection, marking "the first single day with fewer than 100,000 cases since November 2, three long months ago," reported Moser on Feb. 8. On Feb. 12, the seven-day average dropped below 100,000 as well.
Why the drop in new daily cases?
One reason is not a good one: the testing rate has dropped, according to The Covid Tracking Project's analysis on Feb. 11 of what they call 'the third surge.' "Testing dropped 8 percent this week, the third week of declines for that metric." However, cases dropped by 23% during that week.
Sunday CNN host Fareed Zakaria asked his guest, Dr. Tom Frieden, a former Director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention for President Barack Obama, "Is this all happening because more and more people, at least in the U.S., are getting vaccinated, or is there some other explanation?" ["The Good News & Bad News on Covid-19," Feb. 14. See transcript.]
"No, I don't think the vaccine is having much of an impact at all on case rates," responded Frieden. He pointed to two reasons for the drop in cases:
- Behavior: "It's what we're doing right, staying apart, wearing masks, not traveling, not mixing with others indoors."
- The holidays are behind us: "Basically, we're getting over a -- a huge surge around the late-year holidays, starting with Thanksgiving and on to the December holidays."
Fareed followed up by asking when we will see the impacts of increased vaccination—almost 12% of the country has received at least the first dose of a vaccine, according to The Washington Post global tracker on Feb. 15.
"At what point will that start to drive things down, you know, to -- moving closer to herd immunity?"
"In terms of the impact of the vaccination program, what I think will happen is that, within the next few weeks, we'll see substantial decreases in deaths in nursing homes and people over 65," replied Frieden.
"And that is an impact of the vaccines kicking in because they're quite protective.
"But in terms of case rates, it will be many months before we have a big impact from vaccination on the number of cases. That's why it's still important to wear a mask and limit the number of people that you share indoor air with who aren't in your household."
Alternative viewpoint on drop in cases
Dr. Paul Offit, an infectious disease expert at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia and "one of the world's recognized leaders in vaccinology," according to Howard Bauchner, editor of the Journal of the American Medical Association who interviewed him on February 11, saw the reason for the drop in cases differently—an increase in immunity from both natural infection and vaccination.
Offit appeared on CNN Newsroom the next day and shared the same analysis with anchors Jim Sciutto and Poppy Harlow (transcript):
...[I]t's mid-February, this is a winter respiratory virus that should be raging now, but it's not. I mean, we have a decrease in cases, a decrease in deaths, a decrease in hospitalizations.
And there's one reason for that, I think: immunity. We have -- you list on your site that there's 27 million people who have been infected, but that's just people who have been tested and found to be infected. Most people who had been mildly or asymptomatically infected have never been tested.
So how do you figure that out? You do antibody surveillance studies to see who's been exposed. And when that's been done -- it was done in November, before the vaccines were out -- that number is off by a factor of four. There's probably 80 to 100 million people in this country who have already been exposed to this virus...
In the JAMA Network podcast, "Coronavirus Vaccine Update With Paul Offit," he warned of two obstacles that could reverse the progress: "Whether coronavirus variants become a problem and whether the anti-vaccine movement or anti-vaccine sentiment becomes a problem."
Offit's optimism notwithstanding, the IHME model paints a grim projection of 615,000 deaths by June 1. As for the "four key factors that will determine how the next few months unfold," they were noted by both Offit and Frieden.
"The first two will likely help the pandemic numbers continue a downward trajectory: increasing vaccinations and declining seasonality -- the pattern of lower transmission that's likely in the US during the spring and summer months," write Maxouris and Andone of CNN in the source article. The other two "can slow or even reverse the declines that have begun," the IHME team said.
The second is what Dr. Frieden warned: "increased behaviors that favor Covid-19 transmission," add Maxouris and Andone.
"Transmission has been contained over the winter through mask wearing, decreased mobility, and avoidance of high-risk settings such as indoor dining," the team said.
That's why experts say now is not the time for the US to let down its guard, even as a growing list of governors loosen Covid-19 restrictions.
Related in Planetizen:
Herd Immunity Finds Receptive Audience in White House and Florida, October 18, 2020
- The U.S. in Free Fall, July 7, 2020
- The Great Scandinavian Pandemic Experiment [includes a discussion of herd immunity through infection], May 13, 2020
Planning for Congestion Relief
The third and final installment of Planetizen's examination of the role of the planning profession in both perpetuating and solving traffic congestion.
Minneapolis Housing Plan a Success—Not for the Reason You Think
Housing advocates praise the city’s move to eliminate single-family zoning by legalizing triplexes on single-family lots, but that isn’t why housing construction is growing.
New White House Housing Initiative Includes Zoning Reform Incentives
The Biden administration this morning released a new program of actions intended to spur housing construction around the United States.
Proposed Transit Line Would Connect Downtown Tucson to Airport
Based on community input for a 15-mile transit line, residents want to see a focus on affordable housing development and anti-displacement measures.
Strip Malls as a Housing Solution
The American strip mall may be a dying breed of commercial development, but could the buildings serve a new use as sustainable housing?
Study: Most of Vancouver Is a ‘15-Minute City’
A large majority of Vancouver residents can access a grocery store in 15 minutes or less by bicycle or on foot.
City of Redwood City
City of Rohnert Park
City of Hot Springs
This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.