Will Developers Slow the Path to Net Zero?

Cities around the world are demonstrating that net zero carbon buildings—including net zero low-income housing—can be built cost effectively.

5 minute read

January 21, 2021, 5:00 AM PST

By Joan Fitzgerald

Green Building

Felix Mizioznikov / Shutterstock

Cities with aggressive climate standards such as net zero or 100% renewable energy by 2050 are running into roadblocks. Achieving these goals will require strong building energy codes and ending the use of fossil fuels in buildings for space and water heating and cooking. We're starting to see that neither the natural gas utilities nor the real estate industry is going to sit by quietly as cities and states enforce stronger building codes and ban natural gas infrastructure in new construction.

It just happened in Massachusetts—a state considered a leader on energy efficiency and climate change. In November 2019, the town of Brookline passed a bylaw banning natural gas infrastructure for space and water heating in new construction and major renovations. While Brookline was the first in Massachusetts, more than 41 cities nationally have codes that eliminate or minimize natural gas in buildings.

The Home Builders and Remodelers Association of Massachusetts was a vocal critic of the bylaw, as was the American Gas Association and the American Petroleum Institute, which threatened court challenges of the law. It passed anyway but was stopped by state law.

In July 2020, Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healey reluctantly ruled that Brookline's bylaw prohibiting installation of oil and gas lines in new and substantially renovated buildings violates state preemption law—meaning that cities and towns cannot pass energy requirements stronger than the state's code. Massachusetts is one several states in which cities and towns cannot impose stricter building energy codes than the state.

Meanwhile, the legislature was putting together a landmark climate bill that would require the state to achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050 with interim goals each decade (e.g., reduce emissions by 50 percent below 1990 levels by 2030). The net zero goal would be achieved by increasing energy-efficiency requirements in appliances and increased reliance on offshore wind and solar power. A key provision would allow cities and towns to adopt net zero codes—meaning that a building is very energy efficient and completely powered by renewable energy produced either on- or off-site. Both the NAIOP (National Association of Industrial and Office Properties) Massachusetts and the Greater Boston Real Estate Board, came out against the legislation, on the grounds that it would increase construction costs.

Governor Charlie Baker listened. The legislature passed the bill on January 4th, but Gov. Baker vetoed it on the 14th, saying, "One of my big concerns is I've gotten a lot of incoming [sic] from a lot of folks who are in the building and home construction business who have said that certain pieces of this bill, which remember I can't amend and send back, literally may just stop in its tracks any housing development in the commonwealth and those words get my attention." 

To his credit, Baker has supported strong climate legislation, and is a leader in a recent major multi-state effort, the Transportation and Climate Initiative Program (TCI-P), which will employ a "cap and invest" program to reduce motor vehicle pollution by at least 26 percent by 2032. Leaders of both houses of the Massachusetts Legislature are committed to reintroducing the bill in the next session, and, with negotiation, some form of the bill will pass. But if the argument that construction costs are too high to justify aggressive building efficiency standards can prevail in Massachusetts, we need to make a stronger case if similar policies are to pass elsewhere.

While it's true that net zero construction currently can cost 5-10 percent more than standard construction, these buildings cost considerably less to heat and cool. Researchers are demonstrating how technological design of energy systems in the early design phase reduces costs. The U.S. Department of Energy's National Renewable Energy Lab came to the same conclusion in 2012. As the standard becomes more common, the cost differential goes down. A study by the Rocky Mountain Institute estimates that the cost of building to the standard will decline by half by 2050. We won't get to these efficiencies without building codes requiring the standard. 

California illustrates the potential savings to consumers. The state now requires that all new residential construction bet zero net energy and commercial by 2030. In addition, half of all commercial buildings must be retrofitted to the standard by 2030. Since then, several California cities have become leaders in the field. For residential construction, the standard adds $40 to a monthly mortgage payment, which is offset by an $80 per month return on heating, cooling, and lighting over a 30-year term.

The net zero standard is an environmental justice standard. Low-income families pay a higher percentage of their income on home energy. This energy burden can be as much as three times higher than the average household. Richmond, California, Portland, Oregon, San Francisco, New York State and many other places are demonstrating that building new and retrofitting existing low-income housing to net zero standards is possible. It not only reduces energy burden, but reduces indoor air pollution, a demonstrated public health threat, by eliminating gas appliances.

The horse has left the barn. Leading cities throughout the world are committing to net zero carbon buildings and demonstrating that even low-income housing can be built to this standard cost effectively.

Extractive industries are often seen as the prime obstacle to good policy. But it's an open secret that developers wield immense power the politics of most cities and states. When it comes to urgent climate policy, their short-term interests must not be allowed to call the tune.

Joan Fitzgerald

Joan Fitzgerald is a professor in the School of Public Policy & Urban Affairs at Northeastern University. Her most recent book is Greenovation: Urban Leadership on Climate Change (Oxford Univ. Press). Her most recent article, in the Journal of the American Planning Association, examines five cities that updated their climate action plans to focus on equity and justice.

Aerial view of homes on beach in Maui, Hawaii

Hawaii Passes First Legislation Regulating Short-Term Rentals Statewide

The new law will give counties the power to limit number or short-term rentals and convert existing short-term rental units back into long-term residential housing.

May 13, 2024 - USA Today

Google office building in Virginia.

Virginia Data Centers Draining State’s Water Supply

Being the world’s largest data center hub is having a severe impact on local water resources.

May 9, 2024 - Grist

Entrance to a drive-through car wash at night with green 'Enter' sign.

Ohio Towns Move to Ban New Car Washes

City officials in northeast Ohio are putting limits on how many car wash facilities can open in their towns.

May 16, 2024 - News 5 Cleveland

Grand Coulee Dam in Washington state.

Northwest Power Demand Could Surge as Data Centers, Transportation Electrification Ramps Up

New estimates project a steady increase in electricity demand due to population growth, data centers, and the shift to electric power in homes, buildings, and transportation.

May 17 - Governing

Blurred traffic speeding by on freeway with Los Angeles skyline in background.

California Testing Per-Mile Gas Tax Alternatives

A summer pilot program will test the fairness and efficacy of collection mechanisms for mileage-based fee options.

May 17 - Newsweek

Close-up of 'Pay rent' note in red marker on day 1 of monthly calendar.

After Months of Decreases, Rents Nationwide Are Going Up

Average rents rose by $12 around the country so far this year.

May 17 - Smart Cities Dive

News from HUD User

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Call for Speakers

Mpact Transit + Community

New Updates on PD&R Edge

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Write for Planetizen

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.