Who's Benefitting From Historic Preservation?

As wealthy communities learn to use historic districts to inflate property values, socially conscious urbanists must think twice about the purpose and place of preservation, Will Doig reports.

2 minute read

April 18, 2012, 5:00 AM PDT

By Ryan Lue


The popular image of New Urbanism as a movement centered on local character and human scale lines up nicely with the themes of historic preservation. But when it comes to protecting old neighborhoods, the lines of alliance and opposition are shifting, on account of new trends in how and why communities push for historic designation.

As Doig explains, New York's Greenwich Village tells the story of this sea change: "Fifty years ago, a high-rise urban-renewal project threatened to eviscerate the neighborhood. But local activists successfully quashed it, and the Village, now one of Manhattan's most desirable neighborhoods, has enjoyed historic designation since 1969." And now, after two expansions to the historic district (in 2006 and 2010) and with average apartment prices rising above $2 million, the Preservation League of New York State is pushing to expand it yet again.

Quoting sociologist David Harvey, Doig warns that these moves are turning Manhattan into "the world's biggest gated community," noting the patently anti-New Urbanist outcomes that historic districting can bring about. "Restricting development in pricey neighborhoods, the new thinking goes, not only cements a city's best sections as enclaves for the rich, it has wider anti-urban reverberations. It promotes suburbanization by pricing out the middle class. It prevents densification, the greenest, most efficient use of space and the defining characteristic of cities."

But as Doig points out, the philosophy has its detractors, too: preservation architect Jeffrey Chusid has "written about a working-class historic district in Austin, Texas, whose protected status has helped prevent speculative land grabs." And journalist Roberta Brandes Gratz "says the market itself shows that people like these neighborhoods as they are."

The question, ultimately, is whether history can hold up as an excuse to shield whole tracts of the city from the needs of its present-day citizens.

Saturday, April 14, 2012 in Salon

"Planetizen federal action tracker" logo superimposed over black and white image of US Capitol dome.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

November 11, 2026 - Zachary Whalen

A highway in Washington state.

Washington state to charge fee to drivers with fuel-efficient cars

Revenue from the fee will go towards supporting the state’s highways.

November 17, 2026 - The Urbanist

A rendering of the proposed computing campus and data center, an aerial shot of three rectangular, gray buildings and smaller square, white ones.

Illinois considers spending $1 billion in taxpayer money on data center

A quantum computing campus and data center are currently under construction in Chicago.

November 17, 2026 - Block Club Chicago

The capitol building at sunset.

Senate passes bill overhauling permitting

The bill still needs to pass the House.

4 hours ago - CBS

A data center near the water billows smoke into a clear blue sky.

Did data centers change how voters cast their ballots?

Texas, Ohio, and Georgia all flipped party control. But in rural counties, the effect of local data centers was mixed.

November 20 - The Daily Yonder

An Airo transit driving behind a lake and in front of a dark forest.

Amtrak invests in eight new Airo trainsets

The new trainsets will begin serving passengers in 2031.

November 20 - Mass Transit

FREE Course: Walkable City 1: Why Walkability?

After describing his path towards focusing on walkability as the essence of good planning, Jeff Speck marches through his five principal reasons for making more walkable places.

Reinventing Malls: Planning Alchemy—Turning Gray Fields Into Gold

The course focuses on the opportunities and imperatives that shape reinvention of mall sites.