Shopping: An ‘Obnoxious Industrial Activity’?

  As James Howard Kunstler points out in Home From Nowhere, one of the tragedies of single-use zoning is that it branded shopping as an “obnoxious industrial activity that must be kept separate from houses”.  Ironically, the places where most Americans shop today come pretty close to “obnoxious” and “industrial”. 

2 minute read

May 30, 2009, 2:27 PM PDT

By Diana DeRubertis


 

As James Howard Kunstler points out in Home From Nowhere, one of the tragedies of single-use zoning is that it branded shopping as an "obnoxious industrial activity that must be kept separate from houses".  Ironically, the places where most Americans shop today come pretty close to "obnoxious" and "industrial".  Many suburban shopping centers attract hundreds or even thousands of cars per day - a direct result of zoning and parking requirements. In San Diego, Fashion Valley Mall and Transit Center provides 8000 parking spaces.  That's a fairly high potential for pollution.   Not quite a power plant or a steel mill, but not much more inviting. 



Now that development trends are moving toward mixed-use, a common practice in the last decade has been to locate higher density residential housing next to these monstrosities.   Take a shopping mall, add residential, and you get an instant walkable  "village".  And even though they now have people living next door, these malls still attract half the cars in the county.

One of the more poorly-designed retail centers in California, Westfield Mission Valley in San Diego plans a large expansion  that will include 250 residential units as well as more retail.  In its current form, the congested mall is nearly impenetrable both by car and on foot.   Shoppers can expect to park and re-park just to visit a few stores.  If history is any guide, expansion would mean placing new retail and residential anywhere it will fit.  For example, developers recently located several restaurants in the middle of a Target parking lot near a freeway off-ramp - an impossible setting for pedestrians (see photo).   The expansion plan does seek to eliminate sprawling surface parking lots - an encouraging sign - but there is no mention of a major redesign or limiting parking in general. 

I'd love to live near a shopping street, but would you want to live next to this? 


 

 

 

These aren't the pleasant main streets that Kunstler probably had in mind.



Until developers are willing to part with the big box model, limit parking, and design shopping primarily for transit riders and residents, I'm happy to be zoned away from shopping malls. 





Diana DeRubertis

Diana DeRubertis is an environmental writer with a strong interest in urban planning, a field that is intertwined with so many of today's environmental challenges. Diana received an M.A. and Ph.D. degree in Geography from the University of California at Berkeley, where she specialized in climate change science and policy. She also holds a B.S. degree in interdisciplinary environmental sciences from the University of Pittsburgh.

courses user

As someone new to the planning field, Planetizen has been the perfect host guiding me into planning and our complex modern challenges. Corey D, Transportation Planner

As someone new to the planning field, Planetizen has been the perfect host guiding me into planning and our complex modern challenges.

Corey D, Transportation Planner

Ready to give your planning career a boost?

View of dense apartment buildings on Seattle waterfront with high-rise buildings in background.

Seattle Legalizes Co-Living

A new state law requires all Washington cities to allow co-living facilities in areas zoned for multifamily housing.

December 1, 2024 - Smart Cities Dive

SunRail passenger train at platform in Poinciana, Florida.

Central Florida’s SunRail Plans Major Expansion

The expanded train line will connect more destinations to the international airport and other important destinations.

November 24, 2024 - Hoodline

Rendering of proposed housing development on former Desert Pines golf course in East Las Vegas, Nevada.

Las Vegas Golf Course to Become Over 1,000 Units of Affordable Housing

The project is part of an initiative to build affordable housing on shuttered golf courses.

November 20, 2024 - KTNV

Long row of Bixi bike share bikes parked at station on street in Montreal, Canada.

Montreal Bike Share Breaks Ridership Record With 13 Million Rides

The Bixi system introduced a winter pilot project last year, leading to a rise in winter cycling.

45 minutes ago - The Montreal Gazette

Abandoned oil well against hill covered in blooming orange flowers in Carrizo Plain National Monument, California.

Plugging the Gap: Taxpayers Shoulder the Burden of Orphaned Oil and Gas Wells

Taxpayers, federal agencies, and tribal governments are working to address Arizona's orphaned oil and gas wells, which pose environmental and health risks, while advocates call for greater accountability from oil and gas companies.

1 hour ago - Cronkite News

Yellow Flood Area road sign in Piney Point, Maryland.

Future Floods in Focus: Using AI and Physics to Visualize Disaster Risks

MIT researchers have developed a groundbreaking AI-powered tool that integrates physics-based models to generate realistic satellite images of future flooding, offering communities a powerful way to visualize and prepare for disasters.

2 hours ago - MIT News

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.

Write for Planetizen