Most Public Works Forecasts Off By 100%

A new academic article shows that rail passenger forecasts are regularly overestimated by a staggering average of 106%.

2 minute read

April 13, 2005, 11:00 AM PDT

By Chris Steins @planetizen


" 'How (In)accurate Are Demand Forecasts in Public Works Projects?' examines 183 road and 27 rail projects in 14 countries on five continents, including in the U.S. It found that rail passenger forecasts were overestimated by 106 percent on average, resulting in an actual ridership of less than half of that predicted. For 9 of 10 rail projects, estimates were high, according to the study. One project in eight overshot estimates by more than 400 percent. The study also noted that forecasts are no more accurate now than they were 10, 20, and 30 years ago.

...'My team and I were shocked by our findings. For professional forecasters to be wrong by more than 100 percent and to make no improvement for decades is unheard of. Simple forecasting errors cannot explain this,' Flyvbjerg said. 'By routinely overestimating benefits and underestimating costs, promoters make their projects look good on paper, which helps get them approved and built. The only ones to pay are the taxpayers.' "

The study also covers road investments. For road projects studied, half of all traffic forecasts were found to be wrong by more than 20 percent. This is better than for rail forecasts. But for roads, too, there has been no improvement in the accuracy of forecasts for 30 years, despite millions of dollars spent on improving forecasting models.

From the journal article abstract: This article presents results from the firststatistically significant study of trafficforecasts in transportation infrastructureprojects. The sample used is the largestof its kind, covering 210 projects in 14nations worth U.S.$59 billion. The studyshows with very high statistical signifi-cance that forecasters generally do a poorjob of estimating the demand for transportationinfrastructure projects. For 9out of 10 rail projects, passenger forecastsare overestimated; the average overestimationis 106%. For half of all road projects,the difference between actual and forecastedtraffic is more than ±20%. Theresult is substantial financial risks, whichare typically ignored or downplayed byplanners and decision makers to the detrimentof social and economic welfare.Our data also show that forecasts have notbecome more accurate over the 30-yearperiod studied, despite claims to the contraryby forecasters. The causes of inaccuracyin forecasts are different for rail androad projects, with political causes playinga larger role for rail than for road. Thecure is transparency, accountability, andnew forecasting methods. The challengeis to change the governance structuresfor forecasting and project development.Our article shows how planners may helpachieve this.

[Editor's note: The link below is to a 750KB PDF document.]

Thanks to Chris Steins

Tuesday, April 12, 2005 in Journal Of The American Planning Association

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Get top-rated, practical training

Wastewater pouring out from a pipe.

Alabama: Trump Terminates Settlements for Black Communities Harmed By Raw Sewage

Trump deemed the landmark civil rights agreement “illegal DEI and environmental justice policy.”

April 13, 2025 - Inside Climate News

Logo for Planetizen Federal Action Tracker with black and white image of U.S. Capitol with water ripple overlay.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

April 16, 2025 - Diana Ionescu

Black and white photos of camp made up of small 'earthquake shacks' in Dolores Park in 1906 after the San Francisco earthquake.

The 120 Year Old Tiny Home Villages That Sheltered San Francisco’s Earthquake Refugees

More than a century ago, San Francisco mobilized to house thousands of residents displaced by the 1906 earthquake. Could their strategy offer a model for the present?

April 15, 2025 - Charles F. Bloszies

People walking up and down stairs in New York City subway station.

In Both Crashes and Crime, Public Transportation is Far Safer than Driving

Contrary to popular assumptions, public transportation has far lower crash and crime rates than automobile travel. For safer communities, improve and encourage transit travel.

April 18 - Scientific American

White public transit bus with bike on front bike rack in Nashville, Tennessee.

Report: Zoning Reforms Should Complement Nashville’s Ambitious Transit Plan

Without reform, restrictive zoning codes will limit the impact of the city’s planned transit expansion and could exclude some of the residents who depend on transit the most.

April 18 - Bloomberg CityLab

An engineer controlling a quality of water ,aerated activated sludge tank at a waste water treatment plant.

Judge Orders Release of Frozen IRA, IIJA Funding

The decision is a victory for environmental groups who charged that freezing funds for critical infrastructure and disaster response programs caused “real and irreparable harm” to communities.

April 18 - Smart Cities Dive