California's First Use of 2017 'By-Right' Housing Law

A Berkeley parking lot is the site of the state's first implementation of a controversial landmark law that allows eligible developments with affordable housing to bypass the normal channels for approval if they conform to local zoning laws.
March 14, 2018, 11am PDT | Irvin Dawid
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email Comments

On March 8, a Berkeley developer proposing to develop a 2.2-acre parking lot adjacent to Berkeley's Capitol Corridor train station "filed an application with the City of Berkeley for streamlined approval of a 260‐unit multifamily project that will include 50% affordable housing," according to the press release [pdf] of West Berkeley Investors, a subsidiary of Danville, Calif.-based Blake Griggs Properties. In so doing, they became the first to enact SB-35, sometimes referred to as the state's "by-right" housing law.

The City of Berkeley established its rules – including General Plan and Zoning requirements—that designated this site for housing.

Meeting the current zoning, as well as the inclusion of affordable housing, are two of the main requirements for making developments eligible for the streamlined approval process, and perhaps making 1900 Fourth a test case to for the new law, closely followed by Planetizen last year, to see if works as intended.

We may know within 180 days – that's how long it takes for projects that comply with the law’s requirements to be guaranteed approval, "unheard of in a region where even straightforward housing developments can take three or four years," reports J.K. Dineen for the San Francisco Chronicle.

While all but 13 of the state's 482 cities and 58 counties fail to meet some parts of the state's regional housing needs allocation requirements, thus making them eligible for by-right housing, the percentage of affordable housing necessary in the development varies depending on the city. "In Berkeley — as well as in San Francisco and Oakland — a development must be at least 50 percent affordable to take advantage of the law," adds. Dineen.

The developer's attorney explains why the new law is needed in Berkeley, but the reasoning applies for most of coastal California where the housing shortage is greatest.

“Every infill location in Berkeley  that is suitable for housing has passionate opponents – which is why Berkeley and the vast majority of other jurisdictions in the Bay Area have fallen far behind in approving enough housing  that’s actually affordable to people who work here."

 KPIX 5 (CBS SF Bay Area) reporter, Devin Fehely, reporting from the parking lot, interviews Lauren Seaver of West Berkeley Investors (see newscast).

"It’s been a very frustrating five years and millions of dollars of expense trying to bring affordable housing to this parking lot,” said Seaver.

Seaver is hopeful the new law will help her company cut through years of red tape and force the Berkeley City Council to finally greenlight a project that would build much-needed affordable housing.

“It has very straightforward criteria that says if the project fits the zoning for the location then the city is required to approve it,” adds Seaver.

The law's author, state Sen. Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco), released a statement on seeing the first implementation of the new law.

Expediting the production of housing at all income levels, including badly needed affordable housing, is exactly what SB 35 is about. This project was stalled for years, and now it will move forward with a large amount of affordable housing.

Affordable housing is a major beneficiary of SB 35, since the law streamlines affordable housing in almost every California community. SB 35 ensures that *all* communities add new housing. This goes to show that if we push the envelope on housing – which we did with SB 35 – good things will happen.”

Fehely acknowledges the claim by the Ohlone tribe that the parking lot contains artifacts, though "an archaeological dig found no evidence it had ever been home to a Native American shellmound," reported Berkeleyside via KQED in 2014.

Additional media coverage on the first implementation of SB 35 in California:

Full Story:
Published on Tuesday, March 13, 2018 in KPIX
Share Tweet LinkedIn Email