The 'Deliberately Unkind' Public Art of the High Line
"You could be forgiven for reading the art as a message to less-than-opulent New Yorkers: You’ve lost your place," writes Michael Friedman.
Michael Friedrich has written a lengthy review of public art commissioned for New York City's High Line park and come to the conclusion that, more or less, it has failed us.
"I’ve begun to think the High Line’s art is trolling us," Friedrich writes. "That it’s not so much playful as self-regarding—and deliberately unkind."
The High Line began as an urban reclamation project but the subsequent transformation of surrounding West Chelsea have long made it a frequent topic of meditation on the methods and merits of the urban revival of the last two decades.
"A late-capitalist chimera, the High Line may have the head of a park, but it’s a museum from the neck down," Friedrich writes, but "[e]ven as these objects delight us, they also remind us of the public space we’ve lost and the social inequality they’ve yielded."
Sheila Hicks' new installation, for example, "reflects the strange malfunction of our urban dream of reclamation," while John Rafman's 2017 piece "mostly conjures the social food chain devouring community space."
Robert Hammond, one of the original conceivers of the park, has expressed some regrets about unintended consequences of the High Line's remarkable success, and Richard Florida sees it as reflecting the "double edged sword" of the urban renaissance that he wrote about in The Creative Class: "No question it’s a seductive high-culture attraction—and a palliative for the pains of post-industrial decline. But it winks at us even as it soothes us, calling our attention to the dislocation the park itself has animated."
Full Story:
Published on Sunday, November 12, 2017 in
Topics
- Sea-Level Rise Report: Bad News for South Florida
- The High Cost of Sprawl
- Zero Fare Transit Approved in Kansas City, Missouri
- Updated: Journal Article Calls for the End of Single-Family Zoning
- 'Gentle Density' to Save Neighborhoods
- Comic Illustrates the Capitalist Co-option of Jane Jacobs's Teachings
- Canadian Suburb Sets Sights on 'Mobility Orbit'
- Water Concerns Follow New Development in Montana
- Supreme Court Could Decide on Homeless Public Sleeping
- Updated: Requiring Space for Homeless in New Development
- Seattle Expands Speed Limit Reductions
- Low-Income Housing Tax Credits: 'Erecting Pockets of Poverty'
- Planning for Infill Growth Doesn't Guarantee Development: a Case Study
- How Suburbs Can Help the Climate Fight
- Development Backlash Follows Population and Job Growth in Western States
- Songs About Places 2019
- 'Biggest Carbon Loser' Contest Launching in Seattle
- Walmart to Launch Autonomous Grocery Delivery Program in Houston
- CityLab Sold to Bloomberg
- 'Housing Opportunities Toronto' Plans for 40,000 Affordable Units in Ten Years
