Those of us who cherish cities have much to be grateful for (at least in some cities).

Read Time: 3 minutes

April 2, 2018, 11:00 AM PDT

By Michael Lewyn @mlewyn

White House Seder

Pete Souza / The White House

This weekend marks the beginning of the Jewish holiday of Passover, which in turn begins with a festive meal called The Seder. One of my favorite parts of the Seder is the song "Dayenu." The term "Dayenu" means "it would have been enough" or "it would have sufficed." In this song, participants sing or chant: "If God had done A but not B for us, it would have sufficed; if God had done B but not C for us, it would have sufficed" and so on. It seems to me that the song is designed to review the story of the Exodus from Egypt and related events, while instilling a sense of gratitude in listeners.

It seems to me that this song/poem could be adapted to urbanism—at least in relatively successful cities such as New York. One might start off by saying:

"If New York had the magnificent building stock of the 1920s, but had not added parks and playgrounds, it would have been enough. 

If the city had added parks and playgrounds in the 1930s, but Robert Moses's plans to run expressways through the city had not been stopped, it would have been enough.

If Jane Jacobs had stopped Moses's plans to run expressways through the city in the 1960s, it would have been enough." But of course, the city suffered quite a bit from sprawl and poverty and crime in the 1960s and the 1970s. So I am a bit more grateful for the reforms of the 1970s and 1980s. So I might add:

"If the city had been financially stabilized in the 1970s but not saved the subway, it would have been enough;

If the city had had the subway retrofitted, it would have been enough."

Financial stability and a functional subway in turn made the city more desirable to immigrants (both from the rest of the world and to the rest of the United States). But even though the city was growing again in the 1980s, one thing was missing: safety. Under Mayors Giuliani and Bloomberg, this problem was solved. When Giuliani took office in 1993, New York was more dangerous than many cities (though, contrary to popular conventional wisdom, some cities were more dangerous even then). Today, it is, I think, the safest large city in the United States.*

So I would add: "If the city had become safe, it would have been enough."

Once crime was under control, the city began to tackle quality of life issues such as transportation. Under Mayor Bloomberg, the city began to add bike lanes and pedestrian plazas to make more of the city's streets desirable places to walk and bike. 

So I would add: "If the city had added bike lanes but not pedestrian plazas, it would have been enough; If the city had added pedestrian plazas, it would have been enough."

But just as the ancient Hebrews and their modern descendants have suffered all kinds of post-liberation setbacks and problems, New York and other prosperous cities still have significant problems. The city’s popularity means higher demand for housing and higher rents, homelessness is rampant, and the subway needs a new round of retrofitting. I hope that in a few decades, other writers will be able to add additional lines of Dayenu to this blog post- and I also hope that you can add a few lines of Dayenu for your own city!

*For city crime rates go to The only major cities with lower crime rates are cities like San Jose that annexed huge amounts of suburbia. But among cities trapped within their 1950 boundaries, I am pretty sure New York stands alone.

Michael Lewyn

Michael Lewyn is an associate professor at Touro College, Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center, in Long Island. His scholarship can be found at

Chicago Commute

The Right to Mobility

As we consider how to decarbonize transportation, preserving mobility, especially for lower- and middle-income people, must be a priority.

January 26, 2023 - Angie Schmitt

Sharrow bike markings on black asphalt two-lane road with snowy trees

Early Sharrow Booster: ‘I Was Wrong’

The lane marking was meant to raise awareness and instill shared respect among drivers and cyclists. But their inefficiency has led supporters to denounce sharrows, pushing instead for more robust bike infrastructure that truly protects riders.

January 26, 2023 - Streetsblog USA

View of stone-paved street with pedestrians and "Farmers Market" neon sign on left and old buildings on right in Seattle, Washington

Push and Pull: The Link Between Walkability and Affordability

The increased demand for walkable urban spaces could make them more and more exclusionary if cities don’t pursue policies to limit displacement and boost affordability.

January 27, 2023 - Smart Cities Dive

Aerial view from directly overhead of buses parked in large asphalt lot

U.S. Transit Agencies Face a Financial Crisis

Transit providers around the country are scrambling to find new sources of revenue to replace lagging ridership and reorienting their systems to a future less dependent on daily commuters.

6 hours ago - Smart Cities Dive

Water SUpply

California Rejects Six-State Colorado River Plan, Proposes Its Own

State officials claim a proposal agreed upon by the other six states using Colorado River water disproportionately impacts California farmers.

7 hours ago - Los Angeles Times

Pedestrians in zebra crosswalk with green bike lane in downtown Seattle, Washington with three-story brick building in background

Washington Focuses Road Safety Efforts on Individuals, Neglecting Design

Legislative efforts to reduce traffic deaths could move the needle toward Vision Zero, but state leaders failed to commit infrastructure funds to making structural improvements.

February 1 - The Urbanist

Write for Planetizen

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.