No, Your City Is Not Overcrowded

One common argument against new housing (especially in Manhattan) is that the city is "overcrowded."

December 6, 2017, 2:00 PM PST

By Michael Lewyn @mlewyn

High Line Crowds

Allison Meier / flickr

In Manhattan (where I live), one common argument against building any new housing is that the city is "overcrowded" and needs fewer people. This argument is not possible to disprove, since "overcrowding" is a subjective concept: my idea of crowding is your idea of energetic. Having said that, the "overcrowding argument" against new housing is based on a questionable assumption: the idea that if you don't build housing, people will just magically disappear from New York and other cities, causing the city to turn into some sort of small-town paradise.

In fact, when people are priced out of Manhattan, they react in a variety of ways. First of all, the very poorest become homeless and sleep or beg on this streets. This makes the streets even more crowded: in addition to dodging other pedestrians, we have to dodge people who are lying down in the street. Some of them sleep in the subways, making the subways more crowded.  

Other people who leave Manhattan move to New York's outer boroughs or to its suburbs. Do they reduce crowding? Not if they work in Manhattan. If they take public transportation, they make the subways and commuter trains more crowded than if they could walk or bike to Manhattan jobs. If they drive, they not only increase traffic congestion but create more automobile-related pollution. If they don't work in Manhattan, they create congestion somewhere else.

Still others move to other metropolitan areas. Do they reduce New York's crowding? I guess so, but at a heavy cost. When a New Yorker moves to a new city, he or she makes that new city a little more crowded. And if the mover drives to work (as most non-New Yorkers do), he or she creates more pollution of various types than would be the case if the mover stayed in New York and rode a subway to work. If the mover's household gets more housing space, they have more space to heat and cool and decorate, increasing their carbon footprint. And if they moves to a less temperate climate (such as the Deep South or the upper Midwest) that person will create more heating and cooling, thus increasing greenhouse gas emissions. (On the other hand, households who move to southern California often reduce their carbon footprint by using heating and air conditioning less, even if they drive more than New Yorkers.)

Moreover, New York's current level of crowding is hardly unprecedented. Manhattan is actually less populous than it was for the first half of the 20th century: in 1910, Manhattan had 2.3 million people, almost 50 percent more than its current population.  Parts of Hong Kong still are far more dense than Manhattan: the Mong Kok district has 340,000 people per square mile, about five times Manhattan's current density and about three times Manhattan's 1910 density. 

Michael Lewyn

Michael Lewyn is an associate professor at Touro College, Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center, in Long Island. His scholarship can be found at

Walkable Urban Commercial District

The Complexities of the '15-Minute City'

What does a '15-minute city' truly mean–and how achievable is it in the U.S.?

July 29, 2021 - Governing

Toronto Freeway

Does Highway Removal Make Cities Healthier?

Highway removal can improve the air quality and health of the immediate environment, but displacement and gentrification threaten to exclude former residents from the benefits.

July 30, 2021 - NextCity

Pioneer Square, Seattle

Tree Equity Score: The U.S. Needs 522 Million More Urban Trees

As climate change intensifies the urban heat island effect, poorer neighborhoods bear the brunt of tree canopy inequity.

July 28, 2021 - The Urbanist

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Hand Drawing Master Plans

This course aims to provide an introduction into Urban Design Sketching focused on how to hand draw master plans using a mix of colored markers.