Most Livable Cities Revisited

This "livable cities" ranking considers transit, walkability, and bikeability.

3 minute read

March 9, 2017, 1:00 PM PST

By Michael Lewyn @mlewyn


Dolores Park

ChameleonsEye / Shutterstock

In response to the many, many attempts to rank cities, I decided a decade ago to create my own "livable city rankings." The rankings addressed crime, transit use, and walkability, and concluded (not surprisingly) that New York was the most livable city if housing costs were not a factor. When I considered housing costs, Ann Arbor came in first. 

A decade has passed, and it occurred to me to see if anything has changed  But rather than using the same methods, I decided to include a variety of different factors, to reflect some of the responses to my first attempt. I decided to use a simple measure of crime; rather than weighing multiple types of crime, I merely double-weighted murder  I did this for two reasons. First, I suspect that homicide is more likely to be reported to the police than, say, a burglary or purse-snatching. Second, it seems to me that focusing on the most major crime sharpens the distinction between the most troubled cities and the rest of the United States. However, this method does have one negative side effect: it required me to focus on major cities, since most suburbs and small towns have very few murders. By contrast, the old method allowed me to compare suburbs to each other. 

I also shifted my transit and walkability measurements. Originally, I used three measurements: transit mode share as a percentage of the poverty rate (to avoid favoring cities where people used transit because they are poor rather than because transit service is excellent), transit mode share, and walking mode share. I kept the first measurement as a method of measuring transit. But the rise of Walk Score allowed me to change the last two measurements: I substituted citywide Bike Score and Walk Score measurements for mode share data; Bikescore allows me to consider the interests of cyclists, and Walkscore allows me to weigh walkability in contexts unrelated to commuting. On the other hand, I lost something by using these measurements: smaller cities and suburbs often don't have a Bike Score or Walk Score. 

Finally, I decided to weigh cost of living a little differently. In addition to including the ratio between home prices and incomes, I also included data on rents (from this study comparing Craigslist ads in various cities). Using rent data had one negative side effect: the study only includes the 50 or so largest metros, so smaller cities like Ann Arbor and Little Rock got deleted.

My results are on this website, and were slightly different from a decade ago. Without cost of living, San Francisco beat New York by a razor-thin margin: the former city's superior Bike Score pushed it over the top. Boston was a solid third. Seattle was a surprise fourth-place finisher, combining adequate grades on the "car-free" indicia (transit/walking/biking) with crime rates lower than those of other transit metropolises. 

What happened when I gave my two cost of living factors (rent, home costs) equal weight with crime and walkability? Seattle was a surprise first-place finisher, and Minneapolis and Salt Lake City an even more surprising second and third, respectively. These cities were not superlative in any way, but performed adequately in every category while New York and San Francisco were dragged down by housing costs. Last place was a much easier call. Birmingham, Alabama finished last both with and without cost of living—high crime and poor transit were a deadly combination.


Michael Lewyn

Michael Lewyn is an associate professor at Touro University, Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center, in Long Island. His scholarship can be found at http://works.bepress.com/lewyn.

Sweeping view of Portland, Oregon with Mt. Hood in background against sunset sky.

Oregon Passes Exemption to Urban Growth Boundary

Cities have a one-time chance to acquire new land for development in a bid to increase housing supply and affordability.

March 12, 2024 - Housing Wire

Aerial view of green roofs with plants in Sydney, Australia.

Where Urban Design Is Headed in 2024

A forecast of likely trends in urban design and architecture.

March 10, 2024 - Daily Journal of Commerce

Cobblestone street with streetcar line, row of vintage streetlights on left, and colorful restaurant and shop awnings on right on River Street in Savannah, Georgia.

Savannah: A City of Planning Contrasts

From a human-scales, plaza-anchored grid to suburban sprawl, the oldest planned city in the United States has seen wildly different development patterns.

March 12, 2024 - Strong Towns

Aerial View of Chuckanut Drive and the Blanchard Bridge in the Skagit Valley.

Washington Tribes Receive Resilience Funding

The 28 grants support projects including relocation efforts as coastal communities face the growing impacts of climate change.

March 18 - The Seattle Times

Historic buildings in downtown Los Angeles with large "Pan American Lofts" sign on side of building.

Adaptive Reuse Bills Introduced in California Assembly

The legislation would expand eligibility for economic incentives and let cities loosen regulations to allow for more building conversions.

March 18 - Beverly Press

View from above of swan-shaped paddleboats with lights on around artesian fountain in Echo Park Lake with downtown Los Angeles skylien in background at twilight.

LA's Top Parks, Ranked

TimeOut just released its list of the top 26 parks in the L.A. area, which is home to some of the best green spaces around.

March 18 - TimeOut

News from HUD User

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Call for Speakers

Mpact Transit + Community

New Updates on PD&R Edge

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Write for Planetizen

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.