Ink Blot or Bird Sh**? Museum Design Tests L.A.’s Urban Psyche

Buried beneath the enthusiasm that’s accompanied the unveiling of Peter Zumthor’s design for the Los Angeles County Museum of Art is one important criteria by which the project should be evaluated: how does it contribute to the urban environment?

July 25, 2013, 4:15 PM PDT

By Jonathan Nettler @nettsj

Buried beneath the breathless enthusiasm that’s accompanied the unveiling of architect Peter Zumthor’s design for a remade Los Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA) is one important criteria by which the $650 million endeavor should be evaluated: how does it contribute to the urban environment?

Photo © 2013 Museum Associates/LACMA

While the challenges of fundraising and questions over whether to preserve the museum’s hodgepodge of current buildings have received the most attention, the mega-building’s impact on the surrounding streets has received little. In a city looking to break free from its car-centric past by facilitating alternative means of transportation and pedestrian-oriented environments, this is dispiriting. This is, after all, a public building sitting on public land. It’s imperative that the building serves the city, and not just the whims of an ambitious director and his design prophet.

From Welton Becket and Associates’ Music Center (1964) to Richard Meier’s Getty Center (1997), Los Angeles has a history of designing its cultural campuses as islands in the city. In fact, when LACMA was completed in 1965, William Pereira’s three original galleries were separated from Wilshire Boulevard by a moat.

LACMA circa 1965. Photo © 2013 Museum Associates/LACMA, photographic archives

L.A. also has a history of neglecting its public spaces. But with new parks (large and small), new trails, tactical interventions, community events, and an expanded transit system, that’s beginning to change. The City, or County in this case, should be building pedestrian-friendly environments, especially adjacent to the location of a future station along the “subway to the sea”.

So, how does the museum think of its relationship to the street and the larger city? In the last decade, LACMA expanded to the west and north with new buildings designed by Renzo Piano. Unfortunately, the results of this expansion aren't exactly encouraging. Though Chris Burden's Urban Light piece provides a fine forecourt, the Broad Contemporary Art Museum is a 60,000 square foot behemoth whose hulking south façade turns its back to Wilshire Boulevard, providing a blank backdrop for auto-oriented billboards.

Street view of Broad Contemporary along Wilshire Boulevard, from Google Maps

Rethinking LACMA’s campus provides an opportunity for one of Los Angeles’s premier public institutions to re-engage with a changing city where walkability and bikeability are becoming paramount to drivability. Located on a prominent site along the city’s densest thoroughfare, and within close proximity to transit, LACMA has a responsibility to deliver people-oriented architecture, rather than a design oriented to the view from the sky, or what Danish designer Jan Gehl calls “bird shit” architecture.

Who cares whether the building looks like a lake, flower, or inkblot from 500 feet above? How does it look to a family walking along Wilshire Boulevard?

Photo © 2013 Museum Associates/LACMA

Could Zumthor’s design be an improvement over the current campus? Perhaps. As Christopher Hawthorne indicates, the design is preliminary. Elements like cladding, lighting, and landscaping have yet to be articulated. A more porous relationship to the street and increased visibility for the artworks suggested by the current design could create a more pleasant pedestrian experience. Though the oppressive environment suggested by the relentlessly black model Zumthor’s team has built looks more appropriately scaled for the Columbian mammoth recovered from the neighboring La Brea Tar Pits than a human being.

Photo © 2013 Museum Associates/LACMA

Los Angeles doesn’t need more exorbitant trophy objects, it needs great places. And our discussion of this proposal should reflect that.

Jonathan Nettler

Jonathan Nettler has lived and practiced in Boston, Washington D.C., San Francisco, New York, and Los Angeles on a range of project types for major public, institutional, and private developer clients including: large scale planning and urban design, waterfront and brownfield redevelopment, transit-

Los Angeles, California

The End of Single-Family Zoning in California

Despite a few high-profile failures, the California State Legislature has approved a steady drumbeat of pro-development reforms that loosen zoning restrictions. The state raised the stakes on its zoning reforms this week.

September 19, 2021 - Office of Governor Gavin Newsom

The city of Siena in Italy, located on a hillside and bathed in Tuscan sunlight.

Building on Jacobs: The City Emergent; Beyond Streets and Buildings

A science of cities reveals the way cities grow, and why.

September 20, 2021 - Fanis Grammenos

Rendering of St. John redevelopment site

Austin 'Right to Return' Policy Implemented for the First Time

A North Austin development will be the first approved under the city's new Right to Stay and Right to Return policies, aimed at preventing displacement in gentrifying neighborhoods.

September 16, 2021 - Next City

New Updates on The Edge

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

New Case Study Posted on HUD User

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Hand Drawing Master Plans

This course aims to provide an introduction into Urban Design Sketching focused on how to hand draw master plans using a mix of colored markers.