Should We Let Main Streets Disappear?

Kaid Benfield pens a provocative column in which he suggests that the traditional American Main Street is a thing of the past, and may no longer fit our modern retail economy. Are traditional main streets still worth preserving and emulating?

1 minute read

February 4, 2013, 2:00 PM PST

By Jonathan Nettler @nettsj


Empty Main Street

Allan Ferguson / Flickr

While he stops short of suggesting it would be better to let small town main streets fade rather than focus resources on preserving and invigorating them, Benfield is clearly conflicted about whether traditional main streets, and not just the concept of "Main Street," still have a role to play in the retail and cultural future of America. 

Traditional main streets, he argues, are "now something that used to be, much more than something that is....Even the Main Streets that are relatively healthy today evoke the past, not the present."

"The places in America that still have successful Main Streets likely have special economic circumstances, such as a tourist economy, a truly remote location, or a surrounding or nearby wealthy suburb whose residents like the historic, walkable atmosphere for certain occasions but go to the mall or a big-box to buy clothing or electronics."

While he states at the outset that he "sometimes [thinks] the traditional American Main Street is a terrific model worth preserving and emulating," he concludes that if "[t]here’s no need for a horse-and-buggy or an icebox anymore; maybe we no longer need a barbershop next to a children’s clothing store next to an insurance office, either."

Monday, February 4, 2013 in NRDC Switchboard

"Planetizen federal action tracker" logo superimposed over black and white image of US Capitol dome.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

November 11, 2026 - Zachary Whalen

A road in north eastern Nebraska with power lines on either side, and grassy fields.

Eastern Nebraska is running out of electricity

Data centers and electrification are straining eastern Nebraska’s grid, throttling economic development.

November 6, 2026 - Grist

People walking and cycling on a street in Boston.

Study reveals best places in the U.S. for cycling, walking

New research from Streetlight Data examines bicycle and pedestrian miles per capita in the 100 largest U.S. cities by population.

November 8, 2026 - Smart Cities Dive

A rendering of the new nuclear reactor site, which is a large, gray, rectangular building.

Next-generation nuclear reactors are coming to Texas

The reactors will not require towering containment structures thanks to new safety features.

November 16 - Inside Climate News

A rendering of The Portal, a major project in the Bay Area that will extend Caltrain by two miles.

California distributes $1.3 billion to prevent transit service cuts, bolster projects

Twenty-eight projects across California received a portion of the funding.

November 16 - Mass Transit

A worms-eye view of the green-domed Penn capital building.

Pennsylvania Democrats have 15 affordability, clean energy bills for flipped state Senate

Bills in consideration include a bill supporting geothermal energy and a bill supporting solar on warehouses.

November 16 - Inside Climate News

FREE Course: Walkable City 1: Why Walkability?

After describing his path towards focusing on walkability as the essence of good planning, Jeff Speck marches through his five principal reasons for making more walkable places.

Reinventing Malls: Planning Alchemy—Turning Gray Fields Into Gold

The course focuses on the opportunities and imperatives that shape reinvention of mall sites.