Bus vs. Rail: An Oversimplified Comparison
Most comparisons of bus and rail systems assume a classic city with a central business district that commuters need to reach, and that each serve a single function, say Jeffrey R. Brown and Gregory R. Thompson of Florida State.
Brown and Thompson compared data from San Diego, Atlanta, Minneapolis and Pittsburg, and concluded that a combined rail/bus system is the most effective.
"The debate generally overlooks the several other functions that express bus and rail transit modes might serve, and thus it ignores the fact that the two modes perform differently depending upon the regional transit service mission that they are assigned. Transit planners and policymakers who are considering whether to invest in one mode or the other cannot make an informed decision without simultaneously considering the mission to which one mode or the other will be assigned."
The PDF is only available for purchase or in the printed Transportation Research Record.
Full Story:
Published on Wednesday, December 9, 2009 in
Topics
- Infographic: Space Allocation by Population in 15 U.S. Cities
- A Tipping Point in the Geography of the Creative Class?
- Master-Planned Cities in the Spotlight
- Op-Ed: Lakewood's Growth Cap Is 'Climate Arson'
- SUVs Kill Pedestrians—and They Have for a Long Time
- Study: Not All Gentrification Effects Are Equal
- Research: Transit Times Determine Social Networks
- No Quick Fixes for L.A.’s Transit Ridership Woes
- Federal Lawmakers Target Electric Vehicles in Transportation Reauthorization
- Plano, Texas Scraps its Growth Plan After Years of Litigation
- Pedestrian Plan Takes Big Step Forward in Milwaukee
- Opinion: Here’s Hoping the New BART Inspector General Can Help Get the Agency Back on Track
- No More 'Manholes' in Berkeley
- U.S. Economic Growth Shows Urban-Rural Divide
- MTA's On-Time Performance in April the Best in Five Years
- A Climate Change Preview Underway in Michigan
- The Great O'Hare Race (And its Discontents)
- Gentrification Enters Preservation Debate Surrounding NYC's Strand Bookstore
- Connect Transit in Bloomington-Normal, Illinois is Growing Ridership
- Toronto Could Give Buses and Streetcars Priority
