Class Conscience: When Is Clean-Slate Planning Okay?

My classmate was up in front of everyone, flapping and flailing, pleading his case and getting shot down at every turn. It was a bit like watching a train wreck in slow motion. It was also kind of like looking in the mirror. I’m just more than halfway through a planning school studio project working on the beautiful (no, really) Lower Schuylkill River in Philadelphia. They’ve teamed up about 15 planner/urban designers with about 45 landscape architects, who, as I mentioned last time, are reasonably bonkers. That was about a month and a half ago; since then, I’ve begun to think maybe I’m the one needing a room with padded walls.

3 minute read

November 9, 2009, 5:44 AM PST

By Jeffrey Barg


My classmate was up in front of everyone, flapping and
flailing, pleading his case and getting shot down at every turn. It was a bit
like watching a train wreck in slow motion.

It was also kind of like looking in the mirror.

I'm just more than halfway through a planning school studio
project working on the beautiful (no, really) Lower Schuylkill River in
Philadelphia. They've teamed up about 15 planner/urban designers with about 45
landscape architects, who, as I mentioned last time, are reasonably bonkers.
That was about a month and a half ago; since then, I've begun to think maybe
I'm the one needing a room with padded walls.

The incident described above was just before our
mid-semester review, and another one of us poor outnumbered planners was making
the same argument I'd tried to make just a week or two earlier. I'd been
similarly flagellated.

Without getting into too many of the boring details, it goes
something like this: Our site is vast-about 20 square miles-and multifaceted,
covered in things that planners find sexy (vacant former industrial land!
preserved riparian edges! hot wetland action!). And the history is rich: Over
the years, the site has encompassed everything from Bartram's Garden, America's
oldest living botanical garden, to the Blockley Almshouse, a famous insane
asylum that had a devastating fire in 1885.

But there are also plenty of spots that give planners
ulcers: active, ugly industry in the form of oil refineries; scrap metal yards;
functioning freight rail running along the river. Good for employment, but
nobody's gonna put these things in a photo sim.

The instructors tell us to "dream big," to come up with a
vision that's going to be grand and majestic. I'm good with that. But when it
comes to translating these ideas into master plans on the ground, we run into a
serious question: What land do we show as developable, and how soon? Take the
bigass oil refinery sprawling across South Philadelphia. Do we decide
unilaterally that, 50 years from now, we'll all be driving electric cars, so
it's safe to assume that those lands will be convertible to parks and mixed
use? What about 80 years from now? What about 20?

To make a broad, sweeping, wholly unfair generalization: The
landscape architects are happy to turn it all green. The planners are a little
more reserved.

Let's say I've come up with a great idea for a vision
statement. (I have.) Where do I get off sacrificing hundreds of important jobs
just because I have a great idea? My classmate made a similar argument: Don't
we as planners have a responsibility to protect existing productive industries
and work with them, not on top of
them?

On the day I had this argument with the professors, I ended
up with my head in my hands.

It shouldn't be too surprising that the suspension of disbelief
won out. For now, we assume that the entire site is developable, and we'll deal
with implementation down the road conscience be damned. In a perfect world,
the elimination of these 1,000 jobs will create 10,000, and we'll find a way to
both celebrate the site's history and ready it for the future.

Maybe we can expand Bartram's Garden. Maybe we'll rebuild
the insane asylum.

Maybe I'll go there and check in.


Jeffrey Barg

Jeffrey Barg is an urban planner at the Pennsylvania Horticultural Society, and received his master's in city planning from the University of Pennsylvania School of Design. He previously worked for seven years as an alt-weekly journalist at Philadelphia Weekly, and wrote the award-winning nationally syndicated column "The Angry Grammarian." When not urban designing, he enjoys biking, playing guitar and banjo, and board-gaming for blood. He earned his undergraduate degree in American history from the University of Pennsylvania, and he thinks Philadelphia is better than your city.

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Cover CM Credits, Earn Certificates, Push Your Career Forward

Logo for Planetizen Federal Action Tracker with black and white image of U.S. Capitol with water ripple overlay.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

July 2, 2025 - Diana Ionescu

Aerial view of town of Wailuku in Maui, Hawaii with mountains in background against cloudy sunset sky.

Maui's Vacation Rental Debate Turns Ugly

Verbal attacks, misinformation campaigns and fistfights plague a high-stakes debate to convert thousands of vacation rentals into long-term housing.

July 1, 2025 - Honolulu Civil Beat

White and purple sign for Slow Street in San Francisco, California with people crossing crosswalk.

San Francisco Suspends Traffic Calming Amidst Record Deaths

Citing “a challenging fiscal landscape,” the city will cease the program on the heels of 42 traffic deaths, including 24 pedestrians.

July 1, 2025 - KQED

Blue and silver Amtrak train at small station.

Amtrak Rolls Out New Orleans to Alabama “Mardi Gras” Train

The new service will operate morning and evening departures between Mobile and New Orleans.

2 hours ago - New Orleans City Business

Large spinning swing ride at Chicago's Navy Pier.

The Subversive Car-Free Guide to Trump's Great American Road Trip

Car-free ways to access Chicagoland’s best tourist attractions.

3 hours ago - Streetsblog Chicago

Aerial view of downtown San Antonio, Texas at night with rotating Tower of the Americas in foreground.

San Antonio and Austin are Fusing Into one Massive Megaregion

The region spanning the two central Texas cities is growing fast, posing challenges for local infrastructure and water supplies.

4 hours ago - Governing