Tyranny of the (Urban) Majority

Tyranny of the (Urban) Majority

Richard Carson

Richard Carson's newest essay, "The Tyranny of the (Urban) Majority," is published in the recent issue of Architecture Magazine. Carson argues that land use planning's urban bias is destroying the land economics and social structure of rural America. He puts forward the argument that the New Urbanists are using a marketing spin that demonizes specific groups in order to sell their urbanist philosophy. He says that since they can't demonize farmers or the rural poor, they have portrayed sprawl as "McMansions." He says that they are selling the equation that "rich people + McDonalds = McMansions" because most Americans like neither.

The essay title comes from the concern expressed by the young Frenchman Alexis de Tocqueville in "Democracy in America." In his book, Alexis de Tocqueville argued that even the checks and balances of the Constitution might not stop the tyranny of a majority of Americans against a minority of Americans. Carson also argues that if urbanites wish to destroy the land economic of the ruralites, then they should be willing to pay for it. If government downzones rural property, then government and the urban taxpayers should compensate for it.

Carson says that the dependent and voracious gluttony of urban citizens – for SUVS and McDonald type fast food – makes them jealous of their more self-sufficient rural counterparts. And for that reason they are willing to relegate them to living in a pastoral land museum with no say in their future.

He closes by saying, "If we truly are seeking to improve livability for humanity, then let us do so by being intellectually honest about the social costs to all citizens-not by using some biased, urbanist propaganda against a minority of our citizens. It's time for the urban majority to pay its fair share-or at least talk about how to make economic reparations to rural America."

Related Link: Tyranny of the (Urban) Majority (Architecture Magazine)

For more information contact:

Richard Carson
12920 NE 227th Avenue
Brush Prairie
WA 98606

Phone: 360-397-2375, ext. 4101
Email: richardcarson@qwest
Web: http://www.carsonessays.org

Posted July 15, 2005

Planetizen Courses logo

Planetizen Courses: Online Training in Urban Planning

Access more than 250 urban planning courses on your computer, phone, or tablet. Learn today, plan for tomorrow.

View Courses

Edmonton, Canada

Planetizen AICP Exam Prep Class logo

Planetizen AICP* Exam Prep Class

90% of students who took our class passed the exam and became AICP* certified.

View Class

image of laptop and class instructor Jeff Levine