Critiquing an AI-Generated Architecture Critic

Artificial intelligence is being used to generate all kinds of content. Can it successfully replace architecture critics, or does understanding place require physical presence?

Read Time: 2 minutes

January 23, 2023, 10:00 AM PST

By Diana Ionescu @aworkoffiction


Exterior of Perot Museum of Nature and Science in Dallas, Texas

The Perot Museum of Nature and Science has drawn criticism for turning its back on the surrounding community, but an AI-generated review suggests otherwise. | Philip Lange / Perot Museum of Nature and Science

After requesting an AI-generated architectural review of the Perot Museum, Mark Lamster, writing in the Dallas Morning News, evaluates the result. Lamster annotates the review with comments, then explains the flaws found in the automatically generated critique.

“To my critical mind, the Perot’s most significant flaw is that it turns its back on the city around it, offering a cold concrete shoulder to the adjacent Arts District. Our computer-generated review suggests just the opposite. Not good.” The review remains glowing, including factual inaccuracies and misunderstandings of the museum’s role in the surrounding neighborhood. As Lamster points out, understanding a building or place requires being there. “But visiting a building in person isn’t possible if the critic isn’t a person at all.”

Because an AI program can’t ‘be there,’ it ends up, like a lazy college freshman, culling what material it can find floating around the internet and regurgitating it in a generic format.”

This may work for public relations, but not for criticism. “Indeed, one of the critic’s essential tasks is to cut through spin, to provide readers with unvarnished, informed opinion, and to do so with a bit of panache.” In Lamster’s opinion, “Of course we all want to be objective (however loaded a term that is, and especially when judging abstract arts), but who wants criticism without personal opinion?”

Ironically, when asked about the limitations of AI-produced critique, ChatGPT nails it, acknowledging its inability to replace, at least for now, human experience and knowledge. The self-awareness of that answer in itself, writes Lamster, “has me worried.”

Friday, January 20, 2023 in The Dallas Morning News

Chicago Commute

The Right to Mobility

As we consider how to decarbonize transportation, preserving mobility, especially for lower- and middle-income people, must be a priority.

January 26, 2023 - Angie Schmitt

Sharrow bike markings on black asphalt two-lane road with snowy trees

Early Sharrow Booster: ‘I Was Wrong’

The lane marking was meant to raise awareness and instill shared respect among drivers and cyclists. But their inefficiency has led supporters to denounce sharrows, pushing instead for more robust bike infrastructure that truly protects riders.

January 26, 2023 - Streetsblog USA

View of stone-paved street with pedestrians and "Farmers Market" neon sign on left and old buildings on right in Seattle, Washington

Push and Pull: The Link Between Walkability and Affordability

The increased demand for walkable urban spaces could make them more and more exclusionary if cities don’t pursue policies to limit displacement and boost affordability.

January 27, 2023 - Smart Cities Dive

Protesters with signs in Atlanta after Tyre Nichols murder

Memphis: Crime-fighting Camera Sheds Light on Police Abuse

The irony is unmistakable. Public surveillance cameras, long controversial in the criminal justice community, provided pivotal video footage of the beating of motorist Tyre Nichols by five Memphis police officers at a traffic stop on January 7.

21 minutes ago - The New York Times

Photo of cars on two-way separated highway with illustrated lines between them indicating tech-driven decisions

How Autonomous Cars Could Impact Energy Use

The complex algorithms used by self-driving vehicle technology use massive amounts of energy, which could lead to a steep rise in carbon emissions as autonomous cars become more commonplace.

1 hour ago - Dezeen

Overhead view of crosswalk with pedestrian median

Safe Streets Grants Announced

The federal Safe Streets and Roads for All program funds planning and implementation for road safety projects aimed at reducing traffic deaths and building safe infrastructure for pedestrians, cyclists, and other vulnerable road users.

2 hours ago - U.S. Department Of Transportation