The Inclusionary Zoning Debate

New York City's groundbreaking Mandatory Inclusionary Housing Program will turn five years old in March. While some call for the program to be eliminated, others defend it.

3 minute read

January 13, 2021, 5:00 AM PST

By James Brasuell @CasualBrasuell


Manhattan

Felix Lipov / Shutterstock

New York City's Mandatory Inclusionary Housing (MIH) program recently inspired a back-and-forth debate in the pages of City Limits.

Sandy Hornick and Lynn Ellsworth both write articles on the subject of New York City's Mandatory Inclusionary Housing (MIH) program, adopted by the New York City Council in 2016 and championed by Mayor Bill de Blasio as a component of the Housing New York Plan.

Ellsworth writes first, describing the MIH program as a failure for falling short of its lofty targets of affordable housing creation. Among a list of failures, Ellsworth includes: "The MIH policy doesn’t work. As of December 2019, only 2,000 'affordable' units of the promised 80,000 have actually been built under the policy. Surely that is a sign of failure." Instead of building affordable housing, argues Ellsworth, MIH "[floods] upzoned neighborhoods with luxury housing, mostly in the form of towers, creating a kind of gentrification on steroids that displaces existing residents and the small businesses that served them."

Ellsworth proposes six policy alternatives to MIH, including incentives for accessory dwelling units, community housing trusts, building on city-owned land, and single room occupancy buildings, among other prescriptions.

Hornick follows with a rejoinder, immediately taking exception to the fundamental issue of how many affordable housing units have been delivered by the MIH program.

Ms. Ellsworth asserts that the city promised that the MIH program would deliver 80,000 affordable apartments but only delivered 2,000. No such promise was ever made. The promise of 80,000 new affordable dwellings was made in 2014 but relates to the total new construction anticipated over 10 years in the Mayor’s Housing New York Plan from all of the city’s programs. At the end of fiscal year 2020—seven years into the program—the city had financed just over 50,000 new units. That’s a little off the pace needed to get to 80,000 newly-built homes in 10 years but comfortably within reach of exceeding 70,000. Falling short of the goal by 10 percent or so may not be a point to brag about but adding over 7,000 new affordable apartments a year is a pretty remarkable accomplishment.

According to Hornick, it's not market-rate housing development that causes gentrification and rising housing costs, as suggested by Ellsworth, but its lack. "In New York City—for at least the past four decades—the shortfall in housing production has resulted in a market pushing up the price of existing housing to the substantial detriment of the less affluent."

As noted by Hornick, the MIH program is only applicable in neighborhoods that have been rezoned since the implementation MIH, which until recently hadn't included any of the more affluent neighborhoods in New York City. The ongoing process of rezoning NoHo and SoHo in Manhattan, along with Gowanus in Brooklyn, will change that dynamic. 

Thursday, December 31, 2020 in City Limits

Ornate, tan stone capitol building with a gold dome roof and low-rise city buildings in the background.

States Are Banning Guaranteed Income Programs

Four states now have laws in place that prevent cities and counties from creating or continuing guaranteed income programs, and several more have tried or are trying.

May 23, 2024 - Bloomberg CityLab

Aerial view of Oceanwide Plaza skyscrapers covered with graffiti tags.

LA’s Abandoned Towers Loom as a “$1.2 Billion Ruin of Global Capital”

Oceanwide Plaza, shuttered mid-construction after its developer filed for bankruptcy, has stood vacant on prime Los Angeles real estate since 2019.

May 21, 2024 - The Architect's Newspaper

Close-up of electric stove range with front burners red-hot.

California Cities Suspend Natural Gas Bans Following Court Ruling

A Ninth Circuit court ruling forced Berkeley to reverse its ban on natural gas in new buildings, prompting other cities to suspend their own efforts to promote all-electric buildings.

May 28, 2024 - East Bay Times

BART heavy rail train on elevated track pulling into Concord, CA station with cloudy sky and trees in background.

Bay Area Transit Projects Awarded $18 Million

The funding supports eight ‘near-term’ projects slated for completion within the next one to three years.

3 hours ago - Contra Costa Herald

Silver UTA On Demand transit van in Utah.

Utah On-Demand Transit Hits 1 Million Rides

The service connects outlying communities with fixed-route transit lines.

4 hours ago - Utah Transit Authority

Texas Flood

Texas Flood Plan Shows One in Six Residents Live With Flood Risk

One-fourth of the state’s land falls within 100-year or 500-year floodplains.

5 hours ago - The Texas Tribune

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.