Why the Poor Cannot Move: It's Not Just the (Official) Rent

A discussion of the book Evicted, and in particular its suggestion that rent in poor neighborhoods is not much lower than the rent in middle-class areas.

Read Time: 3 minutes

October 14, 2019, 2:00 PM PDT

By Michael Lewyn @mlewyn


Tenants' Rights

a katz / Shutterstock

I recently read Matthew Desmond's book Evicted; one of the author's more interesting observations is his suggestion that renters in poor neighborhoods pay only a little less than renters in richer neighborhoods. First, I did a little research to see if current economic reality backs up his claim. A large chunk of Evicted is about College Mobile Home Park in the South Side of Milwaukee, where trailers rent for about $480 per month. By contrast, in middle-middle-class Cudahy, the cheapest one-bedroom apartment advertised on Craigslist is a little over $600, and the median rent is just under $800. Even if neighborhoods like Cudahy are a little more expensive than Desmond’s research suggested, they still cost only a few hundred dollars more than the mobile home park. So why do the down-and-outers profiled in Desmond’s book live in trailer parks or poor neighborhoods?

Let us assume, for the sake of argument, that the contract rent for a destitute tenant in a lower-class area is the same as the contract rent in the average neighborhood. It does not necessarily follow that the former tenant can easily move to the average neighborhood, for several reasons.

First of all, Desmond’s book shows that lower-class tenants do not always pay the contract rent. He notes that in the poorest neighborhoods, landlords are sometimes willing to accept partial payment if a tenant is not unduly troublesome, or seems likely to get more income in the future. Thus, the rent is a sticker price subject to negotiation. By contrast, in middle-income areas with higher rent, I am not sure if this is the case; if I started paying half my rent, my landlord in Midtown Manhattan might not be as indulgent as the trailer-park landlord profiled by Desmond.

Second, many landlords in middle-class areas have created a variety of policies designed to screen out tenants who cannot pay the hoped-for rent. Even when I lived in cities much cheaper than Manhattan, I usually had to pay a security deposit for an apartment- something that tenants with no savings probably cannot afford. In addition, I usually have to supply the names of prior landlords as references and undergo a credit check; a tenant with a history of evictions will probably not have good references from prior landlords, and a credit check will usually disclose the tenant’s financial problems. So the reference/credit check process is likely to exclude a destitute tenant even from a fairly cheap apartment; thus, the tenant's only recourse will be the sort of landlord who does not ask too many questions. Such a landlord is most likely to be found in places where nearly everyone is destitute and landlords thus cannot be as choosey as in better-off areas.

In sum, the listed rent alone is not enough to explain why the poor cannot easily switch neighborhoods; landlords tend to prefer tenants who can be counted on to pay rent regularly, and have created policies that exclude tenants who are too poor to be able to do so.


Michael Lewyn

Michael Lewyn is an associate professor at Touro College, Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center, in Long Island. His scholarship can be found at http://works.bepress.com/lewyn.

Books

The Top Urban Planning Books of 2022

An annual list of the must-read books related to urban planning and its intersecting fields.

November 28, 2022 - James Brasuell

Urban separated bike lane with street trees on one side and cars parked on the other

How Urban Trees Save Lives

New research shows a strong connection between a healthy urban tree canopy and lowered mortality rates.

December 1, 2022 - Congress For New Urbanism

Alaska

Anchorage Eliminates Parking Requirements Citywide

Anchorage is the latest city to enact sweeping parking reforms, in another blow to the car-centric status quo of planning.

November 23, 2022 - Anchorage Daily News

Rendering of Van Ness Avenue with Bus Rapid Transit

Some States Use More Highway Funding for Transit Than Others

A news study brings the receipts on state and regional transportation spending.

December 2 - TransitCenter

Station with rown of red Capital Bikeshare parked bikes on Washington, D.C. sidewalk

Bikeshare Ridership Up From Pre-Pandemic Levels

Shared micromobility, particularly docked bikeshare systems, are seeing record growth, but ‘scooter inflation’ may cool riders’ enthusiasm.

December 2 - Bloomberg CityLab

Metro Bus

Free Rides, Overnight Service Considered for Metro Transit in D.C.

Washington, D.C. councilmembers are making a bold commitment to public transit.

December 2 - The Washington Post

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.