Athletes (Like Stallworth) Are Not The Only Ones Who Get Off Easy

If you watched or read the news yesterday, then you likely came across the sentencing of Donte Stallworth. Previously known (maybe) for being an NFL role player, Stallworth will serve a 30 day sentence for hitting and killing a pedestrian named Mario Reyes while driving intoxicated here in Miami Beach. The typical sentence for such an offense in Florida is 4 to 15 years. Stallworth will be released just in time for his NFL training camp. How convenient. 

3 minute read

June 17, 2009, 11:51 AM PDT

By Mike Lydon


If you watched or read the news yesterday, then you likely came across the sentencing of Donte Stallworth.
Previously known (maybe) for being an NFL role player, Stallworth will serve a 30 day
sentence for hitting and killing a pedestrian named Mario Reyes while driving intoxicated
here in Miami Beach. The typical sentence for such an offense in Florida is 4 to 15 years. Stallworth will be released just in time for his NFL
training camp.

How convenient. 

Reactions to the Stallworth sentence are
mixed, running the gamut from satisfaction to outrage, to jaded
assumptions that he is just another NFL bad boy getting a free pass. While you probabaly already know how I feel about the issue, it should be noted that in addition to the 30 day sentence Stallworth's license has been revoked for life and he will serve 1,000 hours of community
service while being under house arrest for
the next two years. He has also agreed to compensate the devastated Reyes family with an undisclosed amount of financial support. All of this, you may say, is a paltry price to pay for irresponsibly taking another's life. 

While the Reyes family is reportedly just looking for closure, and not the worst for Stallworth, Livable Street advocates are likely finding the vehicular manslaughter sentence particularly tough to swallow, but also unsurprising. Indeed, lost in the NFL player brou-ha-ha is the story of Mario Reyes, a 59-year old family man who was simply trying to cross the street to catch the bus home after working the night shift.  Stallworth, clearly acted with fatal negligence and the sentence doesn't seem to match the severity of the crime.  

Yet, NFL player or not, DUI's, hit and runs, and other types of fatal automotive "accidents" are
typically not pursued to the extent that you think they would be. Just read Streetsblog on a weekly basis for a sense of the daily injustices levied against innocent citizens across the country. The media also tends to ignore the humanity of the perpetrators when covering such incidents, instead referring to the vehicle that struck the other car, pedestrian, or immovable object, and not the human behind the wheel. Earlier this spring, David Alpert from the Greater Greater Washington blog summarized this fact by analyzing how media outlets and society use an excessive amount of passive voice when reporting incidents involving motor vehicle crashes, a leading cause of deaths in America at approximately 40,000 a year. David says:

No news story ever began saying, "A person was killed yesterday when he
collided with a bullet moving at high speed in the opposite direction."
Yet that's exactly how news stories about traffic "accidents" often
begin, like this Post story:

Four
people ranging in age from 19 to 21 were killed early yesterday in
Culpeper County, Va., when their car collided with a vehicle that was
going the wrong way, Virginia State Police said.

Police said a Chevy Tahoe sport-utility vehicle was driving on the
wrong side of a two-lane stretch of Route 3 when it struck the Toyota
Corolla about 2:50 a.m.

Certainly, the death of Mario Reyes was not fully intentional, but labeling it as an "accident" as many media outlets have and continue to do does not get it right either. After all, Stallworth blew through a red light while Reyes had the right-of-way (in a poorly marked crosswalk along a limited access, high speed vehicular causeway that he had to cross to reach the bus) and killed him. Clearly, this could have easily been avoided by just following the most routine of traffic laws--a difficult accomplishment when your blood alcohol content is .126.


Mike Lydon

Mike Lydon is a Principal of The Street Plans Collaborative, an award-winning planning, design, and research-advocacy firm based in Miami, New York City, and San Francisco. Mike is an internationally recognized planner, writer, and advocate for livable cities. His work has appeared in The New York Times, NPR, ABC News, CNN Headline News, City Lab, and Architect Magazine, amongst other publications. Mike collaborated with Andres Duany and Jeff Speck in writing The Smart Growth Manual, published by McGraw-Hill in 2009.

courses user

As someone new to the planning field, Planetizen has been the perfect host guiding me into planning and our complex modern challenges. Corey D, Transportation Planner

As someone new to the planning field, Planetizen has been the perfect host guiding me into planning and our complex modern challenges.

Corey D, Transportation Planner

Ready to give your planning career a boost?

MARTA train tracks run in the middle of a six lane highway with an overpass and the Buckhead city skyline of skyscrapers in the background.

How Would Project 2025 Affect America’s Transportation System?

Long story short, it would — and not in a good way.

September 29, 2024 - Marcelo Remond

People in large plaza in front of Zurich Opera House in Switzerland.

But... Europe

European cities and nations tend to have less violent crime than the United States. Is government social welfare spending the magic bullet that explains this difference?

September 26, 2024 - Michael Lewyn

Aerial view of low-rise neighborhood in Los Angeles, California.

California Law Ends Road Widening Mandates

Housing developers will no longer be required to dedicate land to roadway widening, which could significantly reduce the cost of construction and support more housing units.

September 25, 2024 - Streetsblog California

Aerial view of Norwalk, California in daytime.

Norwalk to Lose State Funding After Shelter Ban

A California city will lose access to state housing funds after refusing to end a prohibition on new emergency shelters.

1 hour ago - CBS News

Purple Phoenix light rail train on rail at golden hour.

Will Voters Fund Transportation Measures in November?

An overview of key transportation-related ballot measures that will be decided in November’s election.

3 hours ago - Governing

Set of black headphones attached to small tray of wheatgrass sitting on table against blue background.

Using Sound to Revive Ecosystems and Enhance Biodiversity

This innovative approach leverages the power of sound to stimulate beneficial soil microbes, offering a novel and eco-friendly tool for ecosystem restoration and biodiversity enhancement.

5 hours ago - The Conversation

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.

New Updates on PD&R Edge

HUDs Office of Policy Development and Research

Regional Rail at Mpact Transit + Community 2024

Mpact (formerly Rail~Volution)

Cornell's Department of City and Regional Planning Announces Undergraduate and Graduate Program Information Sessions and Application Details

Cornell University's College of Architecture, Art, and Planning (AAP), the Department of City and Regional Planning (CRP)

Write for Planetizen