The Problem With Anti-Commercial NIMBYism

Some people oppose commercial development in working-class neighborhoods, fearing gentrification. But if nothing that makes a place more desirable can be built, jobs will become less accessible to those neighborhoods—an obviously absurd result.

3 minute read

July 7, 2021, 6:00 AM PDT

By Michael Lewyn @mlewyn

A worn down industrial building in Brooklyn.

Felix Lipov / Shutterstock

Last year, a landowner proposed to rezone some land in Sunset Park (a working-class Brooklyn neighborhood) to permit the construction of restaurants and a hotel. This plan was torpedoed by local politicians because of "Not In My Back Yard" (NIMBY) concerns about gentrification. In particular, rezoning opponents argued that the proposed new businesses would bring high-end retail and high-wage employees to Sunset Park, and that those employees and their customers might want to live in the neighborhood, thus bidding up housing prices enough to displace existing residents.*

If this argument is correct, the only business that would not gentrify a working-class neighborhood is one that pays wages as low as those currently earned by existing residents. If a city consistently applied this view, it would seek to exclude any high-wage jobs in working-class neighborhoods; thus, the residents could never better their economic status without long commutes. It is unclear whether this result would be particularly equitable.  

As far as I know, opponents of the rezoning did not take their arguments this far. Instead, some of them argued that the city should somehow create "green" manufacturing jobs. Presumably, these jobs would pay enough to improve the neighborhood standard of living but not enough to attract college-educated professionals. But even if the city could magically create these jobs, it would not prevent demand for housing from increasing. 

Why not? Labor markets are citywide. Thus, these manufacturing jobs would attract employees who live in other neighborhoods. Because some of these employees might wish to move near the business to shorten their commutes, even the most politically popular employer would raise demand for housing in the neighborhood, and thus create some risk of rising rents. So if the only truly equitable policy is the one that reduces demand for housing as much as possible, all jobs should be kept as far away as possible from working-class neighborhoods—an obviously absurd result.

The city could try to prevent displacement by conditioning the rezoning on anti-gentrification safeguards. For example, city law could provide that to receive the rezonings necessary to locate in a working-class neighborhood, an employer must promise to prevent displacement by subsidizing lower-income housing in the neighborhood. But if no such restrictions exist in suburbs, that employer will find it more profitable to move its business to the suburbs (or to a more affluent city neighborhood not subject to the policy). Unless capital is extremely immobile, the city's restrictions will also reduce the number of jobs in working-class urban neighborhoods. 

The basic idea underlying the objections to the Sunset Park rezoning is: don't do anything that might make the neighborhood more desirable to anyone. Despite its obvious demand-suppressing benefits, this argument seems to me to lead to absurd results.  

*Because of  the decline in demand for urban life caused by rising murder rates, COVID-19 and the related growth of telecommuting, it is not clear to me that gentrification is likely to happen anywhere in New York over the next few years. But for the purposes of this article, I will assume that it is early 2020 and that arguments about gentrification may still be made in good faith.

Michael Lewyn

Michael Lewyn is a professor at Touro University, Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center, in Long Island. His scholarship can be found at

Satalite image of a bright green lake surrounded by brownish-green land

California’s Largest Natural Lake Turns Green With … Algae

A potentially toxic algal bloom has turned Clear Lake in Northern California bright green, fed by increased runoff from human activity.

June 4, 2024 - Los Angeles Times

Three colorful, large beachfront homes, one khaki, one blue, and one yellow, with a small dune in front and flat sand in foreground.

Florida Homeowners 'Nope Out' of Beach Restoration Over Public Access

The U.S. Corps of Engineers and Redington Shores, Florida are at a standstill: The Corps won’t spend public money to restore private beaches, and homeowners are refusing to grant public access to the beaches behind their home in return for federal assistance.

June 7, 2024 - Grist

Multistory apartment building under construction.

New Tennessee Law Allows No-Cost Incentives for Affordable Housing

Local governments in the Volunteer State can now offer developers incentives like increased density, lower parking requirements, and priority permitting for affordable housing projects.

June 10, 2024 - Nooga Today

Three men riding recumbent bikes on paved greenway next to bayou with Houston skyline in background.

Houston Developers Question Mayor’s Stance on Pedestrian Projects

The new mayor’s reversal of road safety projects, some already underway or completed, is raising eyebrows among developers who say residents want walkable, mixed-use streets.

15 minutes ago - Houston Chronicle

Cambridge Kendall Square skyline and MBTA red line train on Longfellow Bridge aerial view, Boston, Massachusetts MA, USA.

MBTA Budget Inadequate for Key Projects

Without additional funding, the agency is ‘barely treading water’ and could be forced to make service cuts in 2026.

1 hour ago - Route Fifty

Walkway at San Gabriel River Park.

From Duck Farm to Parkland

The opening of the San Gabriel River Park expands access to green spaces for residents in the San Gabriel Valley, especially for Avocado Heights and other park-poor communities in the area.

June 12 - San Gabriel Valley Tribune

Write for Planetizen

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.