Screened Subway Platforms Ruled-Out for NYC

The front page photo, "Doomed" on the New York Post on Dec. 4 of pushed subway rider, Ki Suk Han attempting to lift himself from the tracks as a train approaches has captivated many - yet a proposal to prevent it from repeating it is doomed as well.

While the media has questioned whether the New York Post should have published the photo of Ki Suk Han's impending death on the front page, and even questioned the photographer who took the photo, far less attention has been given to measures that could prevent the scenario from repeating - whether the fall on to the tracks is intentional or accidental.

"Seoul's Metro has them, and Paris has been installing them in its aging subway system," writes Dana Rubinstein.  Not only does New York's subway not have them -  there are no plans to install them even in new stations for the Second Ave. line or extension of the #7 subway, both under construction.

Of course, you need not go to South Korea to experience such safety measures - most airport people movers, often going by the term, AirTrain, including those that service JFK and Newark airports, have them.  The platform is separated by doors that only open when a train has arrived, and then they only open to provide access to the train's doors.

"The doors are really the solution to prevent [subway falls] from happening," said Richard Barone, the director of transportation programs for the Regional Plan Association.

Like many capital improvements, it all comes down to cost.

"They’re quite expensive and given the 496 stations, I think that’s the number, it’d be quite prohibitive,” Metropolitan Transportation Authority chairman Joe Lhota, said in March.

Barone argues that it would make sense to install the doors on the new stations on the Second Ave. subway now being built.

M.T.A. spokesman Aaron Donovan said, "Platform edge doors are not currently planned for the new stations on the Second Avenue Subway or the 7 extension. They would present operational challenges and incur long-term maintenance funding costs."

Subway riders will have to continue to do what most know they should always be doing - remaining vigilant on subway platforms. But, if a rider should experience what Ki Suk Han did on Dec. 03, and is unable to get off the tracks, with or without the help of fellow passengers, what should one do? Rubenstein asks the Metropolitan Transportation Authority for advice.

Full Story: No Seoul-style platform doors for NY subways



Screened Metro Platforms in Paris

In Paris, they are installing glass screens and automatic doors on the Metro lines gradually, one line at a time, as part of a plan to convert Metro to fully automated operation - like AirTrain in New York.

Last time I looked, they had converted all the stations on one metro line, and they converted it to automated operation during late night hours, when there are few passengers.

I think the economic feasibility would look very different if New York thought about doing this one subway line at a time and factored in the savings in labor costs.

They could start with a short, relatively lightly used line, such as the Franklin Ave. Shuttle. It would cost relatively little to automate that line as a pilot project.

Prepare for the AICP* Exam

Join the thousands of students who have utilized the Planetizen AICP* Exam Preparation Class to prepare for the American Planning Association's AICP* exam.
Starting at $245

Essential Readings in Urban Planning

Planning on taking the AICP* Exam? Register for Planetizen's AICP * Exam Preparation Course to save $25.
Grids and Guide Red book cover

Grids & Guides

A notebook for visual thinkers. Available in red and black.

City Coasters

Hand-drawn engraved maps of your favorite neighborhoods are divided up across 4 coasters making each one unique.