The Corruption Of Smart Growth
With many developers touting their various projects as "smart growth", the term is losing much of it meaning.
"Remember the 1970s, when the nascent environmental movement spawned an interest in "natural food"? This initially referred to vittles that contained no artificial ingredients and were minimally processed. But soon the corporate food industry co-opted the term and started calling everything "natural," whether or not it was laden with preservatives, fillers, taste-enhancing chemicals and God knows what else.
Thus the term "natural food" lost much of its meaning. The same fate threatens "smart growth." Across the country, developers are starting to use "smart growth" to define whatever it is they happen to be building. It may be happening here, as well."
"Perhaps the term is too vague, because it is being tossed around with increasing abandon. Developers in California are using "smart growth" to describe mega-sprawl projects that meet few if any smart growth criteria, according to a May 30 article in LA Weekly (laweekly.com) by David Zahniser."
"So, maybe the smart growth people - and the New Urbanism folks as well - need to do what the foodies did. They changed the term to "organic" and created certification standards. That's worked reasonably well."
- Login or register to post comments
- Email this page
- New London, Four Years After Kelo - Nov 13, 2009
- Imagining A Better City? Try The SmartCode - Nov 02, 2007
- TODs Prove To Be A Boon For Urban Regions - Jun 13, 2007
- Kelo Home To Be Relocated In Eminent Domain Settlement - Jul 03, 2006
- Last Stand for Property-rights Activists? - Jun 09, 2006
Planetizen picks
Contribute
- The Benefits of Creating Hybrid Zoning Codes
- The Appeal of In-Town Big Box
- The Growing Appeal of Drinking From the Toilet
- How and Why Does an Architect Become Famous?
- Could Good Design Have Prevented the Housing Crisis?
- NY Times Defends the Port Authority
- Expanding the Hong Kong Subway, One Blast at a Time
- Can An Electric Bike Replace A Car?
- The Growing Popularity of Women-Only Mass Transit
- Putting the Bloom Back on the Rose Bowl
Volunteerism Plays Critical Role in Reaching World’s Millennium Development Goals
Maxine Goodman Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University
Feb 10, 2012
Web Seminar: Economic Development in a Digital World: Home-Based Businesses and Virtual Workers
International Economic Development Council
Feb 08, 2012
www.flickr.com
|
The answer is before you
Its called LEED-ND.
Dummies
How could anyone be surprised that developers would catch on to what the NUs were doing?
If the NUs hadn't set such a great precedent with cute new--sub-Urban--communities, then the developers would not have had the template from which to draw up their own cute new suburban communities.
Even the award-winning NU community in Denver (Stapleton) has big boxes and is far from Smart. So, if I am a developer (and I am) it is easy to co-opt a model that was suspect to begin with.
Certification Needed
That is the only solution, I think.
By a reputable and trustworthy organization.
Compact Growth
Compact growth sounds too un-American, like compact cars. Any descriptor will eventually be corrupted by homebuilder/developers.
Smart Growth
Smart Growth was never a very good term. Easily corrupted. A better term is "Compact Communities." Much more concrete and definable.