Nothing really pays for itself (except maybe toll roads)

Arguments over transportation policy often run as follows: HIGHWAY SUPPORTER: Highways pay for themselves! Buses/trains don't! So highways good and everything else bad bad bad! TRANSIT SUPPORTER: But highways create bad externalities like pollution and climate change! So if highways were taxed at their true cost gas would cost a zillion billion cajillion dollars per gallon! (followed by numerous counterarguments and counter-counterarguments that I won't bore you with, except as written below...) It seems to me that these arguments miss one point: even if the highway system as a whole pays for itself, the system is so chock full of cross-subsidies that each individual road doesn't (except for toll roads).

3 minute read

June 26, 2012, 9:30 AM PDT

By Michael Lewyn @mlewyn


Arguments over transportation policy often run as follows:

HIGHWAY SUPPORTER: Highways pay for themselves! Buses/trains don't! So highways good and everything else bad bad bad!

TRANSIT SUPPORTER: But highways create bad externalities like pollution and climate change! So if highways were taxed at their true cost gas would cost a zillion billion cajillion dollars per gallon!
(followed by numerous counterarguments and counter-counterarguments that I won't bore you with, except as written below...)

It seems to me that these arguments miss one point: even if the highway system as a whole pays for itself, the system is so chock full of cross-subsidies that each individual road doesn't (except for toll roads).

Instead, one group of motorists is taxed to pay for projects that benefit another group of motorists.
For example, the interstate highway system was built from gas taxes paid by drivers on existing, pre-interstate roads.

Were these drivers the beneficiaries of the interstates? In rural areas, probably yes.
But in urban areas, only some of the urban drivers were helped by the interstates, while others were not.

Imagine, if you will, the city of Townsville (which could just as easily be Detroit, St. Louis etc). Townsville drivers pay a tax on their gasoline, which is used not to repair Townsville roads but to build an interstate that opens up
the suburb of Sprawlville for development. 10 percent of Townsville residents move to Sprawlville; 1 percent of Townsville residents have their home destroyed to build the interstate.

The 10 percent who move to Sprawlville get a windfall; they pay only 10 percent of the gas tax while the interstate is being built, but get most of the benefits (since they get new homes they like).
The 1 percent who have their homes destroyed are harmed quite a bit, because they lose their homes and neighborhoods (and usually are not compensated, especially if they are renters).

The other 89 percent (the people who want to stay in Townsville) may on balance have been harmed as well. Since they don't go to Sprawville they might not benefit very much from the highway.  Also, their existing neighborhoods often declined because of the highway(s). When the 10 percent moved to suburbia, the 89 percent suddenly had vacant housing in their neighborhoods, housing that was usually filled by poorer people, often causing declining property values, worse schools, and increased crime. And if Sprawlville was a separate city, Townsville's tax base started to decline, causing higher taxes, making Townville less desirable.
So eventually many of the other 89 percent was forced out of Townsville by the highway, just as surely as if they had lost their homes to eminent domain.

In other words, users of new roads benefit from taxes paid by users of existing roads (who are not always the same people). The only way to avoid this problem is to make new roads toll roads and to close them down if they don't break even.


Michael Lewyn

Michael Lewyn is a professor at Touro University, Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center, in Long Island. His scholarship can be found at http://works.bepress.com/lewyn.

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Use Code 25for25 at checkout for 25% off an annual plan!

Redlining map of Oakland and Berkeley.

Rethinking Redlining

For decades we have blamed 100-year-old maps for the patterns of spatial racial inequity that persist in American cities today. An esteemed researcher says: we’ve got it all wrong.

May 15, 2025 - Alan Mallach

Logo for Planetizen Federal Action Tracker with black and white image of U.S. Capitol with water ripple overlay.

Planetizen Federal Action Tracker

A weekly monitor of how Trump’s orders and actions are impacting planners and planning in America.

May 14, 2025 - Diana Ionescu

Rendering of California High-Speed Rail station with bullet train.

California High-Speed Rail's Plan to Right Itself

The railroad's new CEO thinks he can get the project back on track. The stars will need to align this summer.

May 19, 2025 - Benjamin Schneider

Cobblestone street with vintage street lamps in Savannah, Georgia.

Savannah Reduces Speed Limits on Almost 100 City Streets

The historic Georgia city is lowering speed limits in an effort to reduce road fatalities.

15 minutes ago - WJCL

Sign for Loma Alta Park in Altadena, Los Angeles County.

A Park Reborn: Resilience and Renewal in Fire-Stricken Altadena

Rebuilt in just two months after the devastating Eaton Fire, Loma Alta Park now stands as a symbol of community resilience and renewal, even as some residents hope recovery efforts will continue to support housing stability and long-term equity.

1 hour ago - Pasadena NOw

Colorful historic homes in Madrid, Spain.

Spain Moves to Ban 66,000 Airbnbs

The national government is requiring the short-term rental operator to remove thousands of illegal listings from its site as part of an effort to stem a growing housing crisis.

3 hours ago - The New York Times

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.

Write for Planetizen