Lapped on Urban Sustainability - can the US ever catch up?

Walker Wells's picture

Summer travel took me out of the US and back to Sweden for the first time in five years.  While my initial reaction was that things seemed much the same, I quickly realized that the Swedes had quietly pushed forward a number of projects that, if located in the US, would be on the vanguard of sustainability.  But over there it's just called urban planning.

What did I see? The completion of the CityTunnel in Malmo, which takes trains coming over the Oresund Bridge straight into their upgraded and expanded central station.  The thoughtful expansion of the pedestrian-only zone in central Lund (a 1000 year old university town in southern Sweden); expanded bike lanes and bike sharing throughout Central Stockholm; the near completion of the Hammarby District (now settled in so well I had to double check that I was in the "new" part of town); broad public discussion about how to rebuild the messy pinch point in central Stockholm called Slussen (which has nearly every type of transportation moving through it except airplanes - cars, trucks, bikes, pedestrians and yes, boats); privately run passenger train companies (operating due to legislation requiring competion with the national rail system); a fast new train going straight from central Stockholm to the airport; construction underway on an additional tunnel to move trucks through the city without filling local streets with traffic and air pollution; plans to add significant amounts of housing and green spaces to under used inner city districts; and finally an interactive exhibit about setting the future vision for Stockholm, set up on the main shopping street.

While stateside, I've had the chance to see a good number of US cities: Chicago, Denver, Cleveland, Pittsburgh, DC, New York, San Francisco, San Diego, Seattle, Phoenix, New Orleans, Atlanta, Boston, Buffalo, and our flagship of sustainability, Portland. To be sure, there is a lot going on in urban America, and much to be proud of.  Our inner city neighborhoods and downtowns are a thousand times better than the scary nearly abandoned places I remember from the 1980s.  And various iterations of the projects and approaches listed above are either completed or being proposed in various US cities. But it is still a challenge to find them working cohesively in any one place.  Instead we have a fragmented landscape of innovation, the Big Dig in Boston, bike infrastructure in Portland, industrial land revitalization in Atlanta, a new rail line to the airport in Seattle, infill housing in downtown Los Angeles, light rail in Phoenix, LEED ND certified plans for public housing in San Francisco, major transit and commuter rail upgrades in lower Manhattan, etc.

In the sprawl-dominated world of US urban planning this is all significant progress. But in a global context, its easy to feel like we're not pedaling fast enough, or with sufficient conviction. Swedish planners and elected officials have know for years that high-quality infrastructure and well-functioning cities are fundamental to the country's long-term economic vitality. Because of this sensibility, federal funding is allocated to enable on-going urban investments.  In the US, urban investments often get politicized and cast as part of a progressive agenda, and funding for low-income housing, brownfield clean up, regional planning, and non-highway transportation projects have to survive the ideological budget gauntlet.

While these battles may seem vital in statehouses and DC, the rest of the world is not standing around waiting for us to make up our minds. Our slow pace in making our cities more sustainable is only doing us long term-harm.  Because unlike the tortoise and the hare, I don't think the Swedes, or any other country with a coherent strategy for urban infrastructure, are planning to stop for a nap anytime soon.

Walker Wells is director of the green urbanism program for Global Green USA and a lecturer at Pomona College and UCLA.



Roads too

They seem to do roads quite well too:

The Southern Link motorway, part of a fairly tight circumference" beltway" around Stockholm, opened some years ago.

The western side (mostly not underground, extremely busy) has been open for decades.

Now they are building the Northern Link (the Eastern Link is left, and that's in planning and preliminary engineering) .

Southern Link on Wikipedia:

http://en.wikipedia .org/wiki/ S%C3%B6dra_ l%C3%A4nken

Northern Link (being built now):

Handout (in English):
http://www.trafikve s/52050/Norra% 20lanken% 20A4-broschyr_ eng_webb. pdf
(.pdf, 3.73 MB)

Environmental mitigation (also English):

http://www.trafikve s/52035/Milj% C3%B6n%20i% 20fokus-2010- GB_mindre. pdf
(.pdf, 4 MB)

Your a diplomat Walker-thanks

I have spent half my career working outside of the US "system" of growth and appreciate the kind way you have correctly described the American growth model as a solid piece of fragmented crap.

Factoid 34: The United States, with all of it's resources and talent in urban design is shackled by a 2nd rate approach re how it attempts to control and manage growth. We passionately (and incorrectly) believe that it is actually possible to blow ship dip through a wet wool blanket as the Aussie's say when describing a hopeless mess. Free market capitalism, with all it's inherent capacity to drive entrepreurship, makes a lousy pardner for idealized, orderly and co-ordinated regional expansion. Always has (Dickensian London) and always will (Detroit, Cleveland, Manhattan, Sao Paulo, Shanghai, etc)

The sooner we accept this fundamental dichotomy, the sooner we can get on with attempting to build cities in this part of the world

Prepare for the AICP* Exam

Join the thousands of students who have utilized the Planetizen AICP* Exam Preparation Class to prepare for the American Planning Association's AICP* exam.
Starting at $245

Essential Readings in Urban Planning

Planning on taking the AICP* Exam? Register for Planetizen's AICP * Exam Preparation Course to save $25.
T-shirt with map of Chicago

Show your city pride

Men's Ultrasoft CityFabric© tees. Six cities available.

Brand new! Urban Grid City Collection

Each city has its own unique story. Commemorate where you came from or where you want to go.