Proactive Vs. Reactive Transportation Planning

3 June 2009 - 5:00am

Alex Marshall takes a look at Spain's recent record of proactive transportation planning, connecting cities to direct development rather than to connect already successful areas.

"Spain, eyeing the fast trains in France in the early 1990s, opted to build its first high-speed rail line from Madrid to Seville, a beautiful city of Moorish architecture and Flamenco dancers, but not an economic dynamo.

Many thought a better choice would have been to build it between Madrid and the thriving city of Barcelona. Many businessmen already made that journey, and many wanted to do so more quickly and easily.

I rode the new Seville line in 1994, shortly after it opened. I made the 300-mile trip from Madrid to Seville in less than two hours, visiting the Seville World’s Fair and returning to Madrid in time for dinner. Even so, I wondered at the wisdom of making Madrid-Seville the first line in the system.

But over the past 17 years, the line to Seville has jump-started the economy not only of that city but of an entire region of the country, beautiful but struggling Andalucia. And once the rest of Spain saw how well high-speed train travel worked, the network was expanded, to Barcelona and other major cities, as well. There are predictions that by 2020, nine-tenths of the country’s population will be living within about 30 miles of a high-speed train connection."

Full Story: A Bridge to Somewhere
Source: Governing Magazine, June 1, 2009

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I like the article a lot,

I like the article a lot, except for the last paragraph and title. I think it might turn a lot of people off to the whole (very well-versed) argument to compare anything to the infamous Bridge to Nowhere and all the negative connotations it represents. The article makes an excellent point about transportation, but I think it is a big risk to compare it to a project that in the public conscience is the epitome of porkbarrel, earmark, and boondoggle.

--------------------------
Howard F. Kelly II, LEED AP
hfk2nd@gmail.com

Bookmark and Share
"To ignore this space is shortsighted." -- Jennifer Wolch, Director of the USC Center for Sustainable Cities