Amtrak in the Spotlight

The much-maligned rail system is being reconsidered, as gas prices and environmental awareness send people looking for solutions. But can Amtrak step up to the plate?

"The storybook plight of the Little Engine That Could, struggling to make it up a mountain, is a pretty apt metaphor for America's rail system. Limited access, outdated equipment and high ticket prices have been the sorry story of Amtrak, the nation's principal rail carrier, from its beginning pushing most would-be riders to other ways of getting around. But $4-a-gallon gas and chaotic airways are working in Amtrak's favor. In an era when green is hip and mileage matters, trains can't be beat. A diesel locomotive at its most efficient can move a ton of weight 436 miles on a single gallon of fuel, according to the Association of American Railroads, making a full train about 10 times thriftier than your new hybrid. "Hands down, traveling by rail is the most fuel-efficient and least-carbon-intensive way you can go," says Nancy Kete, director of the World Resource Institute Center for Sustainable Transport.

It's a common theme in ecoconsciousness: what used to be the antiquated way of doing things-like growing your own food or harnessing power from wind-is suddenly new again. Amtrak and a handful of commuter rail lines are trying to grab the moment by using environmental friendliness to appeal to new riders and the taxpayers who fund the systems. There are signs the strategy is working. Over the past two years, Amtrak's ridership has increased almost 17 percent systemwide. And the recent spike in gas prices has pushed train ridership to capacity on some routes. A hefty funding package for improvements is currently up for debate in Washington, and Amtrak is already exploring ways to enhance service along popular routes. But getting the system up to speed is a tall order."

Full Story: All Eyes on Amtrak



Minor gripe: Penn Station - NYC

Pennsylvania Station - NYC is looking rather grimy in its Amtrak concourse. The station, named for the old Pennsylvania Railroad around which Amtrak practically revolves (sorry, Chicago hub and California system, but the NEC is the backbone of Amtrak, as ridership numbers show), has been criticized ever since the 1960s for being largely demolished and turning into the basement of a sports arena. That's not the point here. What one does with a basement, given a basement, is the point of this discussion.

First of all, Amtrak is not up to par with the commuter railroads that also use the station (it is a terminal for the Long Island Rail Road and New Jersey Transit), even though its services are considerably more expensive. Its men's room is dirty and run down, with most of the sink faucets not working. Its ceiling is gray and rather grimy. Meanwhile, New Jersey Transit has adorned its concourse with beige walls and so has the LIRR; NJ Transit has also put in pictures and decorations to catch the commuters' interest (along with a ticketed passenger waiting room). While Amtrak has put in a ticketed passenger waiting area as well, it has not exactly done as well with aesthetics and being user friendly as the commuter railroads, and various Amtrak areas are notably dingy. Perhaps a lack of Amtrak money may be to blame for this...perhaps it's partly James Dolan (owner of the Madison Sq Garden, the arena in question) to blame for not being patient on the issue of what to do with his company's property.

The fact remains, however, that Penn-NYC is Amtrak's busiest station, and thus needs an appearance that befits its status and reflects favorably, rather than negatively, upon Amtrak, be it basement or palace.

Prepare for the AICP* Exam

Join the thousands of students who have utilized the Planetizen AICP* Exam Preparation Class to prepare for the American Planning Association's AICP* exam.
Starting at $245

Essential Readings in Urban Planning

Planning on taking the AICP* Exam? Register for Planetizen's AICP * Exam Preparation Course to save $25.

Stay thirsty, urbanists

These sturdy water bottles are eco-friendly and perfect for urbanists on the go.

Brand new! Urban Grid City Collection

Each city has its own unique story. Commemorate where you came from or where you want to go.