City Struggles With Density Issue In Fighting Global Warming
Menlo Park, California, struggles with the compatibility of being green and fighting climate change, while resisting high density housing, even around transit stations and corridors.
Menlo Park is sincere about fighting global warming. It assigned a "50-person task force to study how the city can cut greenhouse gas emissions; and with unanimous approval from the City Council, it is now one of almost 500 U.S. cities that has pledged to address global warming at the local level".
"Although the council recently voted unanimously to endorse the U.S. Mayor's Climate Protection Agreement, the wording was slightly changed to avoid committing the city to supporting high-density and transit-oriented projects."
"But amidst efforts to make Menlo Park as green as can be, the city isn't doing one thing (local) environmental groups say it should: building multiple-story residential projects, with at least 25 condominiums and apartments per acre, near the city's train station and downtown area."
The 135-condo Derry project, planned for a 3.4-acre site opposite the commuter rail station and along San Mateo County's major transit corridor, El Camino Real, was halted after a successful citizen-led referendum effort.
"I'm not sure that denser housing belongs along the Caltrain corridor," said Councilman Cohen, who has emphasized that the council should always put the potential impacts on Menlo Park residents before regional needs".
"Growth is happening no matter what, so we have to plan where people are going to live now, and for the next 25 to 30 years," said Michelle Beasley of Green Belt Alliance. "Land-use decisions and dealing with global warming run hand-in-hand. ... El Camino Real is a prime opportunity for development, and it would be wonderful to see Menlo Park embrace that."
"The kind of density that some of these environmental groups are supporting is too much," said Morris Brown, leader of Menlo Park Tomorrow, the residents' group that led the referendum effort against the Derry project. "I'm not at all convinced that we should pack everybody in a small circle, to save more green space."
- Editorial: Clinging to suburbia
- Planetizen: Land Use Shows Itself To Be Controversial Element In Cool Cities Program
- Almanac: Menlo Park: Opponents of 'Derry' project launch referendum campaign
- U.S. Mayors Climate Protection Agreement (pdf, page 4)
- Loma Prieta, Sierra Club newsletter: “Update from the Sustainable Land Use Committee: Menlo Park and San Carlos”, PDF, pg. 6
- Planetizen: Planning And TOD To The Rescue
- Login or register to post comments
- Email this page
Related News Stories
New Urbanist Town Designed For Ultimate In Green Living - May 10, 2008
All Eyes On Air District's Sprawl Fee Litigation - Aug 31, 2006
Developing The Un-Park In San Francisco's Presidio - Jun 23, 2006
Land Use Takes Back Seat In CA's Global Warming Plan - Jun 29, 2008
Major Land Deal To Protect 240,000 Acres In Southern California - May 09, 2008








you can't be an environmentalist and still drive a car
Unless half of your trips are made without motorized transportation, you are having a detrimental effect on the environment. Of the remaining trips, two-thirds should be by public transit, or you are having a detrimental effect on the environment. It is pure hypocrisy to call yourself an environmentalist and continue to make most of your trips by car.