Koontz Decision: No Big Deal or Blow to Sustainable Development?

In a forceful op-ed, professor John D. Echeverria argues the Supreme Court's recent "blockbuster" land use decision will "result in long-lasting harm to America’s communities." Not so fast, says Rick Hills, the decision offers an "exit strategy".
Mark Fischer / flickr

For two contrasting takes on the U.S. Supreme Court's recent decision in Koontz v. St. Johns River Water Management District, see Vermont Law School professor John D. Echeverria's blistering op-ed in The New York Times and NYU law professor Rick Hills' more measured interpretation in PrawfsBlawg.

Echeverria argues that the ruling "makes it hard for communities to get property owners to pay to mitigate any environmental damage they may cause." 

"Cities and towns across America routinely attach fees and other payment obligations to permits, for example, to support wetlands mitigation banks, to finance roads, to pay for new schools or to build affordable housing," he explains. "While, to be sure, such mandates must be reasonable under the Constitution, the revolutionary and destructive step taken by the court in Koontz is to cast the burden on the government to justify the mandates according to the heightened Nollan-Dolan standard. This is contrary to the traditional court approach of according deference to elected officials and technical experts on issues of regulatory policy. Moreover, this heightened standard will result in a huge number of costly legal challenges to local regulations."

Hills, on the other hand, says the ruling shows a court unwilling, or unable, to "duplicate the work of state courts in policing conditions on literally hundreds of thousands of land-use permits..." 

"Thankfully," he continues, "Koontz carefully preserves a convenient albeit disingenuous 'remedial' exit strategy that should insure that the decision is a dead letter."

Full Story: A Legal Blow to Sustainable Development


building block set

NEW! Build the world you want to see

Irresistible block set for adults when placed on a coffee table or desk, and great fun for kids.
Red necktie with map of Boston

For dads and grads: tie one on to celebrate your city!

Choose from over 20 styles imprinted with detailed city or transit maps.
Planetizen Courses image ad

Planetizen Courses

Advance your career with subscription-based online courses tailored to the urban planning professional.
Starting at $16.95 a month
Book cover of the Guide to Graduate Planning Programs 4th Edition

Thinking about Grad School?

New! 4th Edition of the Planetizen Guide to Graduate Urban Planning Programs just released.
Starting at $24.95