Act, React, Repeat

Nate Berg's picture

Adaptation is a way of life. But we humans have been building our habitats and cities in pursuit of permanence. This is an unreachable goal. Making our cities and communities and lifestyles adapt to outside influences is typically an afterthought. We do tend to react, and we often react very effectively. But solving problems before they happen has never been a strong suit when it comes to urban development. This is especially true with regard to our impacts on the environment. A recent and bizarre example illustrates this point.

The example revolves around water, and takes place in Los Angeles. The city is geographically a desert where water is naturally in low supply -- but because of the marvels of modern engineering and science it is now plentiful enough to meet the staggering demand of 4 million residents.

Reservoirs feed this demand for much of the city. These are big pools of water, often containing tens- to hundreds-of-millions of gallons of water. Like all those abandoned pools in the backyards of America's foreclosed suburban homes, reservoirs get kind of nasty unless they're treated. The chemical chlorine is the most common treatment.

Because water attracts life, bacteria forms in these reservoirs that can be harmful to people and other animals if ingested. So we've solved this potential problem by adding chlorine to the reservoirs. Another chemical that naturally exists in L.A.'s reservoir water is bromide. This is where the problem comes in.

In shorthand, bromide plus chlorine plus sunlight equals cancer.

When sun shines on the water, the chlorine used to keep it clean, and the bromide it contains, a carcinogen forms and effectively poisons the drinking water of hundreds of thousands of people.

But there is a solution: take sunlight out of the equation. Earlier this month the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power began a months-long process of "shading" reservoirs of concern. They're doing this by dropping millions of black-colored plastic balls into the reservoir. The balls are intended to float on the surface and block the sunlight from penetrating the water and causing the carcinogenic reaction.

Balls in L.A. Reservoir - Los Angeles Times

Balls being dropped into L.A.'s Ivanhoe Reservoir. Click the picture to view a video from the Los Angeles Times.

Technically the problem is solved. It's an impressive and innovative solution, and one that makes for a great picture. But it stands as another reminder of the unintended consequences of human action. We had a need that nature didn't serve, so we created a solution. Our solution in turn created a problem. Now we've solved that problem, but what will follow?

We need water, and too many people in the Los Angeles desert rely on the reservoirs to get rid of them. We're stuck in what may end up being a long chain of problems responding to solutions responding to problems again and again.

Human ingenuity is truly amazing, and they way we can solve problems like this is encouraging for our future. But it also should make us pause for a moment and ask ourselves whether we want to keep living a life that continually needs a new bandage over the wound, a new finger in the levee crack, a new source for those most basic needs that keep us alive.

As our cities have faced a number of environmental challenges over the years, we've proven again and again that we can adapt after the fact. Now we need to focus on adapting our approach to development so that we won't need to enter the endless cycle of acting and reacting.

Nate Berg is a contributing editor for Planetizen and freelance journalist.



Michael Lewyn's picture

Nature shmature

Before we get nostalgic for the Good Old Days before water treatment and other forms of technology, let's remember what the Good Old Days brought us: life expectancies in the forties and massive infant mortality. All you have to do is look at sub-Saharan Africa to see how miserable the Good Old Days were.

excellent article

This just goes to show that technological "solutions" have often proved to cause more problems than they solve, and that technological innovation is subject to diminishing returns.

Forget the damned motor car and build the cities for lovers and friends. -Lewis Mumford

Plastic in the Water

This LA Now reader and others already mentioned this, but is it a good idea for black plastic to be mixing with LA's water supply underneath the hot summer sun? I'm talking about leaching, of course.

Then again, the benefits of this practice might outweigh the bromide+chlorine+sunlight issue for all I know.

Prepare for the AICP* Exam

Join the thousands of students who have utilized the Planetizen AICP* Exam Preparation Class to prepare for the American Planning Association's AICP* exam.
Starting at $245
AICP CTP Storefont Display

The first online AICP* CTP exam prep class

Are you ready to take the AICP* Certified Transportation Planner exam?
Priced at $245 for May exam!
Book cover of the Guide to Graduate Planning Programs 4th Edition

Thinking about Grad School?

New! 4th Edition of the Planetizen Guide to Graduate Urban Planning Programs just released.
Starting at $24.95
Book cover of Contemporary Debates in Urban Planning

Contemporary Debates in Urban Planning

Featuring thought-provoking commentary and insights from some of the leading thinkers and practitioners in the field.