A Power Grab For San Diego Planners?

A proposal to combine the planning and development services departments could give San Diego's planning director the power to plan for the long-term -- or perhaps lead to more political scandal.

"William R. Anderson has had a lot to do since the middle of last year when he became San Diego's 10th planning director. At the top of the list is completing a new general plan to guide the city's development for the next generation.

But as of last month, he's wearing an unexpected second and bigger hat, temporarily at least, as the city's new land-use czar.

As part of Mayor Jerry Sanders' inner circle, Anderson now has the power to referee disputes between big-thinking planners and short-term-oriented building-permit processors, between doing the right thing or the most expedient thing.

It's a job he inherited from his former boss, Jim Waring, who lured him out of the private sector in June 2006.

Ironically, Waring's departure catapulted Anderson into a position city planners have been pining for since the 1950s – a bureaucratic power base to put vision into place through regulations and action.

"In some respects, planning has been elevated to its highest level in my memory," Anderson said. "I think from the mayor's perspective, it illustrates the importance he places on planning.""

"In this never-ending story, the recommendation under consideration is to merge the Planning and Community Investment Department, which oversees planning, redevelopment and economic development, with the city's Development Services Department, which handles building permits, to achieve consistency and clear communication.

Anderson oversees those departments, as well as real estate assets, redevelopment, economic development and housing. The current city budget says the entire group of departments includes 764 positions and a combined budget of $130.5 million.

Close up, it appears to be a boring debate over an organizational chart. But from afar, the idea poses the ultimate question for San Diego: Who's in charge and whose priorities are paramount?"

Full Story: Waring's departure as city's land-use czar elevates long-term thinker

Comments

Comments

Seeing as

Bill Anderson, San Diego's current planning director, has already implemented Mayor Jerry Sanders' vision of a small, down-sized government (Indianapolization) by laying off over half the Planning staff, and has a record of pro-mega development as a "consultant" with ERA, it would be quite dangerous to give Bill Anderson that much power.

This is indeed a power grab, with the real implications of essentially handing over control of the ENTIRE development process (with no checks and balances) to the private sector (even though Bill Anderson masks his true intentions with the facade of "New Urbanism" and "Smart Growth").

San Diego has always been a pro-business, right-wing, private sector kind of place, but by allowing Bill Anderson to basically dismantle all that Gail Goldberg worked tirelessly for in the "City of Villages" general plan vision, San Diego is now sliding down the slippery slope of rubber stamping development.

This is not "a power grab for San Diego Planners", it's a power grab specifically for the Jerry Sanders administration and his business elite backers. Bill Anderson is merely the foot soldier in this metamorphosis of San Diego city government.

Prepare for the AICP Exam

Join the thousands of students who have utilized the Planetizen AICP* Exam Preparation Class to prepare for the American Planning Association's AICP* exam.
Starting at $245
Planetizen Courses image ad

Planetizen Courses

Advance your career with subscription-based online courses tailored to the urban planning professional.
Starting at $16.95 a month

Wear your city with style!

100% silk scarves feature detailed city maps. Choose from six cities with red or blue trim.
$55.00

Stay thirsty, urbanists

These sturdy water bottles are eco-friendly and perfect for urbanists on the go.
$19.00