Interventions for Urban Youth: Can Summer Jobs and Mentorship Really Affect Violent Crime Rates?

The effects of the program are striking: Sixteen months after the initial lottery, youth offered OSP were arrested for 43 percent fewer violent crimes than the control group.

4 minute read

August 22, 2015, 1:00 PM PDT

By Penn IUR


Disadvantaged minority youth in the U.S. drop out of school, go to prison, and get killed at startlingly high rates. Only about half of youth in the 50 largest urban districts graduate high school in four years.[1] Almost 70 percent of African-American male dropouts spend time in prison by their mid 30s.[2] And homicide kills more young African-American males than the nine other leading causes of death combined.[3]

When policymakers discuss what to do about these pressing problems, they often talk about the “root causes” of crime and dropout: intractable poverty, failing schools, and changing family structure, among others. All these factors likely contribute to the challenges that urban youth face. But focusing on such broad causes can make finding solutions seem overwhelming. If the only way to make any dent in dropout and crime is to eliminate poverty, then the potential for progress seems limited.

Fortunately, as my recent Science article demonstrates, solving all systemic urban problems is not a prerequisite for improving youth outcomes; much more targeted policy interventions can make a difference. The study, which came out of a partnership with the City of Chicago and the University of Chicago Crime Lab, evaluates a violence-prevention program called “One Summer Plus” (OSP). The program provides summer jobs to disadvantaged high-school students. In 2012, youth were offered a part-time job at Illinois’ minimum wage ($8.25 per hour). In this first year of the program, all the jobs were in the non-profit and government sectors (private sector jobs were added in later years). For 25 hours per week over 8 weeks, youth cleared vacant lots and planted community gardens, worked as camp counselors, and staffed alderman’s offices. Youth were also assigned an adult job mentor at a ratio of about 10:1. The mentor helped teach youth how to be good employees and how to deal with barriers to employment, from family demands to transportation to conflicts with supervisors.

Like many summer jobs programs across the country, OSP is massively over-subscribed; far more youth apply than there is funding to serve. But unlike many summer jobs programs, which select youth either by qualification or on a first-come, first-served basis, OSP selected youth via a lottery. Not only is this a completely fair and transparent way to allocate a limited resource, but it also generates a “treatment” and “control” group, just like a clinical trial in medicine. In the absence of the program, the two groups would have the same average outcomes – the only difference between them is the flip of a coin. So after the program, any difference between them can be convincingly attributed to the intervention itself.

As part of my study, I tracked all 1,634 OSP applicants in administrative data sources such as school and arrest records. Pre-program data shows that the City successfully recruited a very disadvantaged population of applicants. Almost all the youth were African-American and eligible for free or reduced-price school lunches (a proxy for household poverty). They lived in neighborhoods with an average unemployment rate of 19 percent, and about 20 percent of applicants already had an arrest record.

The effects of the program are striking: Sixteen months after the initial lottery, youth offered OSP were arrested for 43 percent fewer violent crimes than the control group (about 4 fewer per 100 youth). This drop occurred largely after the end of the program, suggesting it is not just a mechanical result of keeping youth busier during the summer. There were no changes in other types of crime, or in schooling outcomes like GPA or days present. But the study establishes that summer jobs alongside a mentor – at least in this context – can have a dramatic impact on youth violence.

This first study is just a start. I continue to partner with Chicago (and am starting to work with Philadelphia) to learn more about why the program works, and for whom. But in the meantime, the larger message to cities is that there are ways to make a real difference in the short term. Low-intensity interventions can improve adolescents’ outcomes. And the more cities that follow Chicago’s lead by rigorously testing their own ideas, the more we will learn about how to reduce the toll that dropout and crime take on urban residents.

Sara Heller is Assistant Professor of Criminology in the Department of Criminology at the University of Pennsylvania.

 

[1] On average, only 53 percent of the class of 2005 graduated from these districts in four years (http://www.edweek.org/media/cities_in_crisis_2009.pdf). A more recent average for this set of urban districts is not readily available; it is likely to be slightly (but not dramatically) higher due to slowly rising graduation rates in recent years.

[3] Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Web-based Injury Statistics Query and Reporting System (WISQARS)

Thursday, August 20, 2015 in University Of Pennsylvania

View form second story inside Southdale Mall in Edina, Minnesota with escalators and model cars parked on downstairs floor.

The Mall Is Dead — Long Live the Mall

The American shopping mall may be closer to its original vision than ever.

March 21, 2024 - Governing

View of Austin, Texas skyline with river in foreground during morning golden hour.

The Paradox of American Housing

How the tension between housing as an asset and as an essential good keeps the supply inadequate and costs high.

March 26, 2024 - The Atlantic

Houston, Texas skyline.

Report: Las Vegas, Houston Top List of Least Affordable Cities

The report assesses the availability of affordable rental units for low-income households.

March 22, 2024 - Urban Edge

Aerial view of high-rise buildings on waterfront in Boston, Massachusetts

Boston Moves Zoning Reform Forward

The ‘Squares + Streets’ plan creates form-based zoning templates for neighborhoods that promote mixed use and denser housing near transit.

57 minutes ago - The National Law Review

Aerial view of Anchorage, Alaska downtown with mountains in background at golden hour.

Anchorage Leaders Debate Zoning Reform Plan

Last year, the city produced the fewest new housing units in a decade.

March 28 - Anchorage Daily News

Young man in wheelchair crossing zebra crosswalk.

How to Protect Pedestrians With Disabilities

Public agencies don’t track traffic deaths and injuries involving disabled people, leaving a gap in data to guide safety interventions.

March 28 - Governing

News from HUD User

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Call for Speakers

Mpact Transit + Community

New Updates on PD&R Edge

HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research

Urban Design for Planners 1: Software Tools

This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.

Planning for Universal Design

Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.