Car-Free on Market Street?

"A spokesman for Mayor Gavin Newsom said the idea of banning cars on Market Street is worth studying.

'If it doesn't have a detrimental effect on businesses and is done the right way, then the mayor would be open to it,' said Newsom spokesman Nathan Ballard.

The new study will consider possible impacts on businesses. It also will determine whether removing autos would add to or detract from the unsavory elements that pock much of the mid-Market area between Fifth and Eighth streets.

Does having cars travel up and down the corridor provide an element of safety, particularly at night? Or, could the creation of a pedestrian-friendly corridor bring more life and vibrancy to the struggling area?

Andy Thornley, project director for the San Francisco Bicycle Coalition, said revamping Market Street shouldn't be approached too narrowly. If cars are restricted, the city should make sure that improved amenities are in place for transit users, cyclists and pedestrians, he said."