A Puddle Or Navigable Water?

16 January 2001 - 12:00pm

The Supreme Court rules that an abandoned gravel pit isn't navigable water.

"For the past 15 years, the EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers have regulated nearly every stray puddle in [Illinois]because they just might become a habitat for migratory birds that crossed state lines. Their rulemaking was derisively called the "glancing geese" test, meaning that if a migrating bird even glanced at a water-filled pothole it became part of interstate commerce. Roughly 100 million acres became subject to federal control -- including the gravel pit near Skokie."

Source: Wall St. Journal, January 15, 2001
Bookmark and Share
Under the proposal, the government would assign the populace the task of counting and mapping dog droppings as a first step to greater penalties for owners who fail to clean up after their mutts.