Kyoto Following Its Own Protocol?

19 April 2006 - 8:00am

What does it mean when Japan, the most hopeful follower of the Kyoto Protocol, "acts more American" and pollutes more than expected?

"...contrasting preferences [with environmental implications] have profound implications for the Kyoto Protocol, the treaty to combat climate change that was signed in the city in 1997.

If any country could meet the terms of the treaty and reduce its greenhouse gas emissions, it would seem to be Japan. No other nation has Japan's deep cultural roots in conservation, with everything from religion and art to everyday living habits influenced by the age-old concept of mottainai, the disapproval of waste and excess.

But as the Japanese act more American -- choosing bigger houses and bigger cars, shopping in bigger malls, turning the heat up and blasting the air conditioning -- Japan could become one of the treaty's most notable failures.

While Japan's industries are hyperefficient, cutting their emissions by 1.7 percent since 1990, emissions from the residential sector have grown 29 percent, according to government estimates.

Emissions from the commercial sector are up 37 percent, and those from transportation 20 percent."

Source: The San Francisco Chronicle, April 16, 2006

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Japan flunks Kyoto

Was anyone besides me thinking about the population nexus here?
The nexus, of course, is non-existent.
I believe Japan and Italy are the usual examples of "negative population growth". With Japan's GHG emissions skyrocketing while its population declines, once and for all perhaps todays Malthusians will realize that "population growth" is not the environmental nightmare so many of us thought it once was.

The nightmare appears to be that everyone want to live like an American!
Irvin Dawid, Palo Alto, CA

Bookmark and Share
I argue that the vocabulary of planning and the concepts necessary to participate in local government and planning issues need to be taught to students in K-12.