Is Zoning Replacing Planning?

19 October 2005 - 5:00am

A new piece of legislation going before voters in New York would limit the amount of development in many low-density neighborhoods, and encourage planning over upzoning to encourage development.

"The real problem with downzoning to stop overdevelopment, or upzoning to encourage development, is that they both avoid any serious planning, both in each neighborhood and in the city as a whole. They don’t allow local residents and businesses to address serious concerns they have with everything from housing needs to traffic, because zoning regulations are limited to use and density controls.

...But it remains to be seen how many of the same neighborhoods in New York City complaining about overdevelopment are willing to support planning."

Source: The Gotham Gazette, October 18, 2005
Bookmark and Share
Stuart Meck and Rebecca Retzlaff call the attention of AICP certified planners to an upcoming change to the certification process which they believe will "degrade and cheapen" the AICP designation.